People who know about whisky...
People who know about whisky...
Author
Discussion

fizz876

Original Poster:

2,953 posts

226 months

Wednesday 9th July 2008
quotequote all
Hi

I need to give a gift to someone who I know appreciates a good whisky...I have no clue about whiskies..


I dont want to spend a huge anount but would like to get him something nice at a reasonable price...

Suggestions please....

GetCarter

30,207 posts

295 months

nightfever

914 posts

235 months

Mattt

16,664 posts

234 months

Wednesday 9th July 2008
quotequote all
fizz876 said:
a reasonable price...

Suggestions please....
Very helpful.


fizz876

Original Poster:

2,953 posts

226 months

Wednesday 9th July 2008
quotequote all
Mattt said:
fizz876 said:
a reasonable price...

Suggestions please....
Very helpful.
Sorry but as I dont have a clue about whiskies I dont know what a reaasonable price is...

thehawk

9,335 posts

223 months

Wednesday 9th July 2008
quotequote all
Can't go wrong with a bottle of Jack Daniels really.

GetCarter

30,207 posts

295 months

Wednesday 9th July 2008
quotequote all
thehawk said:
Can't go wrong with a bottle of Jack Daniels really.
smash


thehawk

9,335 posts

223 months

Wednesday 9th July 2008
quotequote all
GetCarter said:
thehawk said:
Can't go wrong with a bottle of Jack Daniels really.
smash
????

Put on some Southern Rock, get in a couple of blonde escorts for the evening - jobs a good'un. smile

mft

1,752 posts

238 months

Wednesday 9th July 2008
quotequote all
Presuming you mean scotch, but have no idea where the recipient's tastes lie, I'd head towards a good edition of a decent mainstream brand - say, Macallan, or Highland Park. They will have a wide range of options, at various price points.

thehawk said:
Can't go wrong with a bottle of Jack Daniels really.
He said good whisky. Neither word applieswink

space1999

436 posts

205 months

Wednesday 9th July 2008
quotequote all
It depends whether you mean scotch or whiskey as technically whiskey is Irish and Scotch is Scotish! Personally I love Glenturret - nice and smooth! Try this site

http://www.whiskyshop.com/

GetCarter

30,207 posts

295 months

Wednesday 9th July 2008
quotequote all
thehawk said:
GetCarter said:
thehawk said:
Can't go wrong with a bottle of Jack Daniels really.
smash
????

Put on some Southern Rock, get in a couple of blonde escorts for the evening - jobs a good'un. smile
An analogy:

I want to buy a really good sports car

www.Porsche.com

www.ferrari.com

Can't go wrong with a Fiat Punto really - put on some lights and chuck in a big stereo - jobs a good'un

11110111

612 posts

216 months

Wednesday 9th July 2008
quotequote all
glengoyne single cask range from £30ish to £300 or so, they also have limited ed bottles picked by workers, labelled with the cask number, the type of oak used and other stuff, all bottle are traceable apparently. they come nicely boxed and should do the job

went there on a whiskey tour a short while back and spent 80 on a single malt & single cask bottle, the wood still smells of the factory, gorgeous, it wont be opened for yet a while : )



Edited by 11110111 on Wednesday 9th July 19:57

OllieC

3,816 posts

230 months

Wednesday 9th July 2008
quotequote all
buy him a bottle of one of the islay single malts

he might not like it, but equally he wont think you are a tasteless moron
erm, so its a win / not quite lose situation

avoid Laphroaig as some people find it tastes too strong (i love it)

perhaps a bottle of Talisker or Oban (Island but not Islay malts), Bunnahabhain or Ardbeg

its hard to reccomend a whisky without knowing what he would normally drink smile

edit - all of which will come in under £30

Edited by OllieC on Wednesday 9th July 20:04

matchmaker

8,795 posts

216 months

Wednesday 9th July 2008
quotequote all
Go for a good malt. Unless you know their taste in whisky, best avoid Islay malts as most are very peaty - my favourites, but an acquired taste!

Highland Park, Glenfiddich, Glenmorangie or Glenlivet all good. Or a less well known one (used to be export only) Glen Ord.

Check out these guys - very helpful! Loch Fyne

GetCarter

30,207 posts

295 months

Wednesday 9th July 2008
quotequote all
I'd also second 'Highland Park'

Great taste and service.

IforB

9,840 posts

245 months

Wednesday 9th July 2008
quotequote all
Another vote for Highland Park. Or something like a 10/12yr old Glenmorangie. Another good general whisky.

I love the Islay malts, but unless you know they like them, it may be totally wasted.

Tampon

4,637 posts

241 months

Wednesday 9th July 2008
quotequote all
OllieC said:
buy him a bottle of one of the islay single malts

he might not like it, but equally he wont think you are a tasteless moron
erm, so its a win / not quite lose situation

avoid Laphroaig as some people find it tastes too strong (i love it)

perhaps a bottle of Talisker or Oban (Island but not Islay malts), Bunnahabhain or Ardbeg

its hard to reccomend a whisky without knowing what he would normally drink smile

edit - all of which will come in under £30

Edited by OllieC on Wednesday 9th July 20:04
I was going to say Laphroaig, same reasons, it might not be to his taste but it shows you have a idea about single malts. Not many know about Laphroaig, and if they have had it they won't forget it. Costs around £20 so won't break a hole in you arse either.

I hate Whiskey, but was sat down one night and had single malts Vs JD and the rest explained by a very drunken friend, then proceeded to show/make me taste his collection and all the different ways you can drink it. God it is a mine field.

If I am around Single malt types I ask for Laphroaig, they give a knowing look, I don't look like a WKD swilling Noob

Also there is one that I actually really like, its been done in a port or sherry cask for half its time ( 24 year one ), can't remember the name now though.

sleep envy

62,260 posts

265 months

Wednesday 9th July 2008
quotequote all
thehawk said:
Can't go wrong with a bottle of Jack Daniels really.
it's not whisky, nor is it a bourbon

it's a sour mash

Wadeski

8,675 posts

229 months

Wednesday 9th July 2008
quotequote all
I prefer Speyside (smoother, fruitier but still some peat) for everyday drinking and Islay for occaisions.

as such, i currently have a Glenrothe 1994 (very very nice) and a Benriach 16 y.o. which is bloody lovely.

smiller

12,172 posts

220 months

Wednesday 9th July 2008
quotequote all
A reasonable scotch, for reasonable money, Johnny Walker Black Label is pretty good.

Again, as mentioned previously, Highland Park is good stuff.

Dimple (if you can find some).

Bruichladdich is another favourite, as is Glen Ord.

I suppose it all depends on what style of whisky one likes. I - personally - am not keen on Islay whiskys.