Green pesto from shop-recommendations?

Green pesto from shop-recommendations?

Author
Discussion

xyz123

Original Poster:

1,046 posts

139 months

Saturday 14th September 2024
quotequote all
Hi, might be a strange one but looking for some suggestions for shop bought green pesto. I know it's easy to make at home hut with different work shift schedules it's difficult to always be organised. We have tried few but fins that many are too sour (we have checked they are in date and stored as per instructions).. So any suggestions please.. Thanks

DoubleSix

12,125 posts

186 months

Saturday 14th September 2024
quotequote all
We like a bit of pesto in our house.

Try making it, it really is a piece of p***.

I always keep a few jars of Waitrose No1 in the cupboard as its the best ive foubd on the shelves… check the % of basil for a indication of quality and of course only extra virgin olive oil.


Mobile Chicane

21,394 posts

222 months

Saturday 14th September 2024
quotequote all
M&S fresh pesto from the chiller section is I think the least worst.

I detest pesto. If it's in a TGTG bag it will be eaten through 'long teeth'.

Why people slather it on everything is beyond me. Especially on chicken.

Best place for it is the fking bin.

nikaiyo2

5,114 posts

205 months

Sunday 15th September 2024
quotequote all
I really like it’s quite well balanced but quite nutty.


soad

33,578 posts

186 months

Monday 16th September 2024
quotequote all
nikaiyo2 said:
I really like it’s quite well balanced but quite nutty.

Looks decent for Pesto Linguine.

DoubleSix

12,125 posts

186 months

Monday 16th September 2024
quotequote all
soad said:
nikaiyo2 said:
I really like it’s quite well balanced but quite nutty.

Looks decent for Pesto Linguine.
Sorry not really. This is made of just 47% basil and uses rape seed oil and just 3% pine kernals!!

The Waitrose one above is 53% basil and uses ev olive oil and 7% pine kernals.

Shopping for food based on “looks” rarely works out well.

Edited by DoubleSix on Monday 16th September 07:36


Edited by DoubleSix on Monday 16th September 07:42

Badda

2,992 posts

92 months

Monday 16th September 2024
quotequote all
How can it be difficult to have pine nuts in cupboard, parmigiano in fridge and a basil plant on the window sill. Jarred pesto is awful.

DoubleSix

12,125 posts

186 months

Monday 16th September 2024
quotequote all
I tend to agree (and lemon juice, garlic and ev olive oil)

MyM2006

248 posts

154 months

Monday 16th September 2024
quotequote all
The only time I've liked pesto is when I've made it fresh, not found a jar I get on with.

I've never used lemon in mine, the acidity is only there to make it keep longer and I guess stay greener but that's not an issue if you're eating it straight away!

Silvanus

6,463 posts

33 months

Monday 16th September 2024
quotequote all
Got to agree with making it, it's very easy. I make a batch and freeze in ice cube trays then into a ziplock bag.

Making your own means you can tweak it and experiment with different ingredients.

soad

33,578 posts

186 months

Monday 16th September 2024
quotequote all
I’m most likely one of the few people who actually prefer (sun dried) tomato pesto, as tend to use in meatball (even lasagne) dishes. Not to fully replace the tomato paste, simply add some on. boxedin

theplayingmantis

4,602 posts

92 months

Monday 16th September 2024
quotequote all
now odd chap as i am i have an excel with various pestos (or what are called pestos as most are nothing of the sort, but thats a different color horse completely...)on it and if there liked or not...as eate it infrequently from shops so always forget whats rank and what isnt.

ignoring all the make your own stuff, then the belazu i find grim, although most of their non genovese 'pesto's' are good, shout out for the rose harissa one.

of the greens the list says sacla and fillippio berio are not great but ok in a non traditonal sense, but the barilla , both the plain and the rocket is nice, albeit very salty, although from memory to call them pestos is a stretch given the texture really isnt a pesto texture. i also have lidl and aldi on there from weekend supplement recommendations but both crap imo.

i was in lidl at weekend trying to find some more biere monaco's with no success, but spotted 2 types made by Polli, so always keen to try an actual italians companies wares, i got one of each, but yet to try.

incidentally the best shop bought i ever had was years ago from either B&M or home bargains, it was again an Italian brand limited run import (not one of the italian brands that sell here normally) but never recalled what it was or what it looked like and never seen it in there again, both that i would know what i'm looking for after so many years.

UTH

9,940 posts

188 months

Thursday 19th September 2024
quotequote all
This thread has inspired me to get around to making my own for the first time.

How long does it realistically last in a jar in the fridge? Wonder if I make enough to keep for a while, or maybe just enough for whatever I'm going to cook.

DoubleSix

12,125 posts

186 months

Thursday 19th September 2024
quotequote all
Best fresh (eaten on the day).

Could freeze in small batches.

dontlookdown

2,014 posts

103 months

Thursday 19th September 2024
quotequote all
UTH said:
This thread has inspired me to get around to making my own for the first time.

How long does it realistically last in a jar in the fridge? Wonder if I make enough to keep for a while, or maybe just enough for whatever I'm going to cook.
Not long. A day or two. Best to only make what you need for one meal.


nikaiyo2

5,114 posts

205 months

Friday 20th September 2024
quotequote all
UTH said:
This thread has inspired me to get around to making my own for the first time.

How long does it realistically last in a jar in the fridge? Wonder if I make enough to keep for a while, or maybe just enough for whatever I'm going to cook.
You know how somethings, when homemade there is joy compared to shop bought, bread, cakes, gravy spring to mind. Pesto falls more into the homemade pickled onions or custard category, its such a small improvement over the right shop bought its not worth the effort.

It also negates pestos biggest use, for me, as a store cupboard thing, something to knock up a quick meal from.

epom

12,680 posts

171 months

Friday 20th September 2024
quotequote all
We use Aldi pesto. They have two types, the cheaper of the two (surprisingly) is much nicer in our households opinion.

UTH

9,940 posts

188 months

Friday 20th September 2024
quotequote all
nikaiyo2 said:
UTH said:
This thread has inspired me to get around to making my own for the first time.

How long does it realistically last in a jar in the fridge? Wonder if I make enough to keep for a while, or maybe just enough for whatever I'm going to cook.
You know how somethings, when homemade there is joy compared to shop bought, bread, cakes, gravy spring to mind. Pesto falls more into the homemade pickled onions or custard category, its such a small improvement over the right shop bought its not worth the effort.

It also negates pestos biggest use, for me, as a store cupboard thing, something to knock up a quick meal from.
Yes, I have a feeling I might discover exactly this situation. I'll give it a go once though, but it is something I can't see how I'm going to make it much better than shop stuff, because I think most of the shop stuff is bloody nice.

DoubleSix

12,125 posts

186 months

Friday 20th September 2024
quotequote all
epom said:
We use Aldi pesto. They have two types, the cheaper of the two (surprisingly) is much nicer in our households opinion.
Sunflower oil and cashew nuts?

I’ll pass.

epom

12,680 posts

171 months

Tuesday 24th September 2024
quotequote all
DoubleSix said:
epom said:
We use Aldi pesto. They have two types, the cheaper of the two (surprisingly) is much nicer in our households opinion.
Sunflower oil and cashew nuts?

I’ll pass.
Sincere Apologies, I hadn’t realized it was only your opinion that the OP had requested.