Hellmans or Heinz

Author
Discussion

asfault

Original Poster:

12,864 posts

189 months

Wednesday 20th December 2023
quotequote all
Now hear me out. Obviously there are budget and supermarket own and also mega high ends.
but of the reasonable middle ground
Iv'e found Hellmans ketchup to be better than Heinz and Heinz mayonaise to be better than Hellmans. which is kinda the wrong way round in terms of the bigger one for each company.

Anyone else the same?

okgo

39,720 posts

208 months

Wednesday 20th December 2023
quotequote all
Hellmans Mayo
Heinz Ketchup

The end.

Defcon5

6,338 posts

201 months

Wednesday 20th December 2023
quotequote all
Hellmans mayo is white slop

Heinz mayo is pure deliciousness

okgo

39,720 posts

208 months

Wednesday 20th December 2023
quotequote all
Defcon5 said:
Hellmans mayo is white slop

Heinz mayo is pure deliciousness
You need to buy the jar version.

Greedydog

936 posts

205 months

Wednesday 20th December 2023
quotequote all
Neither, the Sauce Shop is preferable to both. No Heinz products at all given their recent profiteering.

YorkshireStu

4,418 posts

210 months

Wednesday 20th December 2023
quotequote all
okgo said:
Hellmans Mayo
Heinz Ketchup

The end.
This for me too.

But I prefer Crosse & Blackwell Mayo and have to import that since it isn't sold here.

RobbieTheTruth

1,951 posts

129 months

Wednesday 20th December 2023
quotequote all
asfault said:
Now hear me out. Obviously there are budget and supermarket own and also mega high ends.
but of the reasonable middle ground
Iv'e found Hellmans ketchup to be better than Heinz and Heinz mayonaise to be better than Hellmans. which is kinda the wrong way round in terms of the bigger one for each company.

Anyone else the same?
Yes.

This opinion would have been utter ludicrous a decade or so ago - but it's true now.

Hellman's ketchup is much nicer than Heinz ketchup IMO

Heinz mayo* is much nicer than Hellman's mayo IMO


  • the updated 'Seriously Good' branded one and not their standard cheaper offering that is still available

dickymint

26,265 posts

268 months

Wednesday 20th December 2023
quotequote all
HP brown sauce and Heinz salad cream nuts

Mobile Chicane

21,396 posts

222 months

Wednesday 20th December 2023
quotequote all
dickymint said:
HP brown sauce and Heinz salad cream nuts
Together?

Now you're talking. I'll bet this is wicked on chips.

Lotobear

7,479 posts

138 months

Wednesday 20th December 2023
quotequote all
Mayo - Bramwells (Aldi), much better than either Heinz or Hellmans.

Ketchup - Stokes. End of

Sebring440

2,456 posts

106 months

Wednesday 20th December 2023
quotequote all
Defcon5 said:
Hellmans mayo is white slop

Heinz mayo is pure deliciousness
You've got that the wrong way round!


adsk

92 posts

169 months

Wednesday 20th December 2023
quotequote all
Marks & Spencer Ketchup
Aldi Mayo

dickymint

26,265 posts

268 months

Thursday 21st December 2023
quotequote all
Mobile Chicane said:
dickymint said:
HP brown sauce and Heinz salad cream nuts
Together?

Now you're talking. I'll bet this is wicked on chips.
Will give that a go - love a bit of fusion cookery hehe

Edit: not sure if Wifey would appreciate me trying it out as an alternative to her Marie Rose sauce on the Xmas dinner for the prawn cocktail rofl

twing

5,264 posts

141 months

Thursday 21st December 2023
quotequote all
Crucials Ketchup
Hellmans Mayo

dapprman

2,521 posts

277 months

Thursday 21st December 2023
quotequote all
For me:
Mayo - Hellmans (jar)
Ketchup - Tiptree

RC1807

13,096 posts

178 months

Thursday 21st December 2023
quotequote all
Calvé mayonnaise

Heinz is a fair runner up

Hellmann's doesn't make the top 5

jonsp

1,075 posts

166 months

Thursday 21st December 2023
quotequote all
For me Heinz Seriously Good Mayonnaise. Just wish it came in a jar rather than a squeezy bottle. I have mayo with my breakfast more than once the bottle run low and have to get in with scissors to get a decent scoop out. Wrong.

Don't like ketchup but Mrs always buys Tesco own brand so assume she's happy with that.

NSNO

416 posts

162 months

Thursday 21st December 2023
quotequote all
asfault said:
Now hear me out. Obviously there are budget and supermarket own and also mega high ends.
but of the reasonable middle ground
Iv'e found Hellmans ketchup to be better than Heinz and Heinz mayonaise to be better than Hellmans. which is kinda the wrong way round in terms of the bigger one for each company.

Anyone else the same?
I don't think that I've ever had either of Heinz mayonnaise or Hellmans ketchup to be able to comment.

Countdown

42,785 posts

206 months

Thursday 21st December 2023
quotequote all
I used to think Hellman's was the best until I tried Heinz. It is surprisingly good.

Hants PHer

6,063 posts

121 months

Thursday 21st December 2023
quotequote all
I think the Heinz 'seriously good' mayonnaise is foul, really don't like it. It's far too sweet.
In the Hants household, we have tried every brand of mayo, pretty much, and we always come back to the stand out winner: Hellmann's. Jar or squeezy, makes no difference.

As for ketchup, that's easy too: Heinz.

In both cases, you can forget your 'Lite' or <shudder> vegan versions, or anything other than the normal/original version.