Have I bought a fake?
Have I bought a fake?
Author
Discussion

Sterillium

Original Poster:

22,371 posts

255 months

Saturday 14th January 2017
quotequote all

Hi all...

I will try to add photos to this thread at some point, as it might not be much good without them, but, for the knowledgeable horologists amongst you, a little help please:

Last week a I bought a new G-Shock watch, to replace the one I have worn daily for about five years. I find them to be great as super-tough daily watches, happy to be battered, abused, bumped about and covered in all manner of substances without ever needing more than a good scrub.

My previous one was a G314-RL - black, simple, did the job. In fact I only replaced it because it ran out of battery and I noticed the strap was beginning to split (I may now simply replace the strap and continue!).

The one I bought last week was GA-100-1A1ER - I chose this because it is big and chunky, also in plain black, I thought a bigger watch would suit my wrist even more.

Now I only paid £60, with a RRP of £110 popping up in various places, so I thought I'd got an OK price for what I assumed would be a bigger, chunkier version of my trusty old G314-RL. But almost as soon as I got it out of the tin, it felt a bit odd.

It's very light, feels very plasticy (I mean I KNOW it's plastic!) and kind of cheap. The strap is just plastic / rubber (none of the layered flexible material like the old one) and the light, instead of lighting up the face, is a little orange light that hardly allows the face to be seen in the dark!

Have I picked a light, plasticy model or are G-Shocks just not as robust now?

Or is it a fake?

It has the tin, the warranty card, the back of the watch is all inscribed the same as the G314-RL is, which I know was genuine.

Maybe they just don't make things like they used to?

Sterillium

Original Poster:

22,371 posts

255 months

Saturday 14th January 2017
quotequote all
An eBay watches "PowerSeller" - so lots of feedback and lots of happy customers, had I bought it from a market stall I'd be more inclined to expect a fake!

Mikebentley

8,684 posts

170 months

Saturday 14th January 2017
quotequote all
I have almost identical model, mine has red on face.Light is a little orange glow. They are not as heavy as you might expect. I paid £59.99 about 6 years ago. Fingers crossed it is probably real. PS mine has taken loads of stick and looks like new..and still original battery

Mikeyjae

1,007 posts

136 months

Saturday 14th January 2017
quotequote all
I have the same watch but red and black and I can confirm the backlight is useless. I also payed roughly around the £60 mark. Cant help with yours without pictures but at least you know the back light is useless.

Sterillium

Original Poster:

22,371 posts

255 months

Saturday 14th January 2017
quotequote all
Sounds like they're lighter and less solid than they used to be... The "backlight" isn't even a backlight on mine, it's just an orange light in the face (not very useful) but I think we are describing the same thing.

If it takes half as much punishment as my last one, I'll be happy.

Mikeyjae

1,007 posts

136 months

Sunday 15th January 2017
quotequote all
I have used mine daily at work for about a year and not a single scratch. Its robust enough and I knock it daily against metal and rubber materials.