Hesitation on revving and acceleration on Mk1 1.6

Hesitation on revving and acceleration on Mk1 1.6

Author
Discussion

neil_bolton

Original Poster:

17,113 posts

270 months

Friday 20th November 2009
quotequote all
Ello all,

The previous owner mentioned to me this problem and I've experienced it first hand a few times now, having been out and given the car a proper thrapping to get to know her.

The engine is fairly strong - admittedly its taking a while to get used to a revvy thrashy 4 cylinder again coming from a silky large capacity straight 6, but it seem strong enough.

However, occasionally, it will get it's knickers in a twist and start to get hesitant when you put your foot down or pull away from a standstill.

Quite often giving it some beans past 3k will clear it's throat, but yesterday it got very upset and left me stranded at the lights unable to start her for a minute or so.

Eventually it got going.

A wiggle of the ignition leads seemed to make it go away briefly, but it's back again and I'm keen to solve it.

I'm thinking that a set of spark plugs and new ignition leads would be a good start, and then looking to clean the MAF?

What do the resident beards think?

tuttle

3,427 posts

243 months

Friday 20th November 2009
quotequote all
Hi there. From what you describe, it does sound like replacing plugs/leads might be the solution. I think the MAF is hot wire type & so probably not really serviceable.

neil_bolton

Original Poster:

17,113 posts

270 months

Friday 20th November 2009
quotequote all
tuttle said:
Hi there. From what you describe, it does sound like replacing plugs/leads might be the solution. I think the MAF is hot wire type & so probably not really serviceable.
Seems from what I've read re: the MAF, you're right.

I'll do the plugs first.

Whilst I'd like to get them from MX5parts - do Halfords do them - i.e carry them in stock?

snotrag

14,829 posts

217 months

Friday 20th November 2009
quotequote all
HT leads.

Seems to be the most common thing people have to change when buying an old MX5.

Plugs are a fairly standard type I think.

Leads can be had from Moss, Mx5parts, etc etc.

How are you finding the car? I drove mine exclusively for a year-ish, now I have another car its made me realise how much you have to get used to short gear ratios and having to thrape it everywhere.

It takes a bit of getting used to, (or not, I guess for some lunatics) to get used to it, but you soon learn that you CAN thrash the living daylights out of the car and they just seem to love it.

People say they are 'slow' but if driven in the correct manner then they will hold their own - certainly I've never had my pants pulled ALL the way down on any PH runouts with the more sensible cars.

The correct manner, of course, means regular excursions past the 6 on the tacho.

A by-product of this is you get rifle-cracks from the exhuast on changing up too hehe

driving

tuttle

3,427 posts

243 months

Friday 20th November 2009
quotequote all
Best stick with NGK plugs which are OE on a '5. You want, NGK BKR-7E-11 or the long reach plugs which are only a couple of quid more (improvement gains are negligable IMHO) NGK ZFR-6F-11. You can get em at Halfrauds.

neil_bolton

Original Poster:

17,113 posts

270 months

Friday 20th November 2009
quotequote all
snotrag said:
How are you finding the car? I drove mine exclusively for a year-ish, now I have another car its made me realise how much you have to get used to short gear ratios and having to thrape it everywhere.

It takes a bit of getting used to, (or not, I guess for some lunatics) to get used to it, but you soon learn that you CAN thrash the living daylights out of the car and they just seem to love it.

People say they are 'slow' but if driven in the correct manner then they will hold their own - certainly I've never had my pants pulled ALL the way down on any PH runouts with the more sensible cars.

The correct manner, of course, means regular excursions past the 6 on the tacho.

A by-product of this is you get rifle-cracks from the exhuast on changing up too hehe

driving
Well I got dusted by a super old Honda Civic V-Tec with 3 up in it - but I think they're sometimes a bit quick anyway so that doesn't count.

It's quick enough - it's a completely different car to the BMW - whilst it does the same thing that the BMW does, it does it in a way that is so much more alive - the BMW cossetted you, kept you feeling safe - you never felt like you'd fall off the road if you didn't concentrate - wheras the MX5 feels like you need to be awake.

Which is perfect.

I've also spent much of my time sideways hehe

snotrag

14,829 posts

217 months

Friday 20th November 2009
quotequote all
Sideways is the new forward.

ETA - Oh and if you unbolt the pax seat you can get a downhill bike in too...!

Edited by snotrag on Friday 20th November 10:16

neil_bolton

Original Poster:

17,113 posts

270 months

Friday 20th November 2009
quotequote all
snotrag said:
Sideways is the new forward.

ETA - Oh and if you unbolt the pax seat you can get a downhill bike in too...!
I have been told by a friend who had an MX5 that a bike rack and two bikes fit well on the back tongue out

6k, sideways on the lock. Bosh.


MX-5 Lazza

7,952 posts

225 months

Friday 20th November 2009
quotequote all
I'd say just the leads. It's very rare for the plugs to be a problem in these cars unless it's been running lean or rich for a long time which is highly unlikely on a standard car. Leads however are a very common problem.

pmanson

13,387 posts

259 months

Friday 20th November 2009
quotequote all
More than likely the leads.

Autolink are a good source of parts (both new and second hand) and i've used MX5Parts on a number of occasions without any issues

neil_bolton

Original Poster:

17,113 posts

270 months

Sunday 22nd November 2009
quotequote all
Right, replaced the leads, same problem.

Seems to always happen when the car is warm.

Today, after a nice long drive it got so upset that eventually it stalled when we came to a stop, the car having kangerooed and generally seemed as if it was being overfuelled.

Tonight, in the wind and the rain, and the girlfriend tuttutting in the car, I turned it over and over, hoping it'd sort it's throat out, but no.

Eventually it failed to even catch - turning over but no fuel it seemed.

However I gave it ten minutes to cool down, and it was absolutely fine.

So, it seems it only happens when hot.

Searching about is pointing me at the crank position sensor: can anyone confirm this?

It's either that or the coil pack - both are £250!!!

So much for this cheap motoring lark!


MX-5 Lazza

7,952 posts

225 months

Sunday 22nd November 2009
quotequote all
Hmmm... Coil pack is a possibility but so is temp sensor on the back of the engine. Could be a number of things but that's where I'd start. Do you know anyone locally with a 5 that you could "borrow" a coil pack from to verify if it's the cause?
If you need to buy then go to MX5 Heaven or Autolink.

pmanson

13,387 posts

259 months

Sunday 22nd November 2009
quotequote all
You could try dumping a load of carb cleaner in there.

Is the idle lumpy?

neil_bolton

Original Poster:

17,113 posts

270 months

Monday 23rd November 2009
quotequote all
Thinking about it all, and chatting to other people at work, I think it is the sensor (whichever one) as my BMW 328 experience exactly the same issue - a replacement cam/crankshaft sensor solved the issue on that...

RVVUNM

1,913 posts

215 months

Monday 23rd November 2009
quotequote all
This sounds the same as the problem I had. After changing the leads/plugs/coil pack I finally got to the green temp sensor at the back of the block...........bingo,sorted. If this sensor is faulty it sends all sorts of duff info to the ECU and runs rough and rich, give it a go it worked for me.

neil_bolton

Original Poster:

17,113 posts

270 months

Monday 23rd November 2009
quotequote all
RVVUNM said:
This sounds the same as the problem I had. After changing the leads/plugs/coil pack I finally got to the green temp sensor at the back of the block...........bingo,sorted. If this sensor is faulty it sends all sorts of duff info to the ECU and runs rough and rich, give it a go it worked for me.
Hmm. Would make sense. Plus, it's the cheaper of the sensors: I may try this first, whilst depositing a tin of carb cleaner through the throttle body...

MX-5 Lazza

7,952 posts

225 months

Monday 23rd November 2009
quotequote all
I'm sure I read somewhere that you shouldn't use carb cleaner on them - something to do with the injectors not liking it I think...

pmanson

13,387 posts

259 months

Monday 23rd November 2009
quotequote all
http://www.planetmx5.com/forum/viewtopic.php?p=536...

Mine was ok when I followed a similar guide

ironictwist

7,127 posts

211 months

Monday 23rd November 2009
quotequote all
neil_bolton said:
It's quick enough - it's a completely different car to the BMW - whilst it does the same thing that the BMW does, it does it in a way that is so much more alive - the BMW cossetted you, kept you feeling safe - you never felt like you'd fall off the road if you didn't concentrate - wheras the MX5 feels like you need to be awake.

Which is perfect.

I've also spent much of my time sideways hehe
I've walked the same path...Now I'm back in a very cosy & comfy XJ with a creamy V8 & I can't tell you how much I miss driving my '5 to work, even in the tipping rain it would be roof down all the day.

It's a different kind of fun which you just can't replicate with a tintop thumbup

MX-5 Lazza

7,952 posts

225 months

Monday 23rd November 2009
quotequote all
If it's a "strip down/clean up/put back together" job and not a "spray into intake while engine is running" job then that's ok. Just make sure no pieces of carbon/gunk/tissue/cloth etc. are left in the intake. If even a small piece of cloth gets caught in a valve it can cause serious damage to the valve.