Looking at getting an MX5

Author
Discussion

SiC2

Original Poster:

148 posts

212 months

Monday 12th May 2008
quotequote all
Well this week i turn 20 years old and fancy a change in car and fancy a convertible so the MX5 is a logical place to look my parents use to have a MK1 1.8 Dakar. I started off looking at the Mk3 but have decided that there still a little to expensive for the spec i would like. SO have started looking at the Mk2.5 and like the look of the Nevada special edition? I started looking at the 1.8 thinking that they would be a better buy than the 1.6 as they are only a 1 group higher on the insurance, but now am thinkin maybe the 1.6 is a better choice evem tho its less powerful due to a difference in insurance costs of around £400.

buccal

533 posts

199 months

Monday 12th May 2008
quotequote all
Mark 2.5 is a great drive, IMHO preferred it to the mark 3 but i'm sure other's will differ.

These cars are not about straight line speed so if insurance is an issue then you'll still have lots of fun in the 1.6

Buccal

Edited by buccal on Monday 12th May 12:19

skinny

5,269 posts

242 months

Monday 12th May 2008
quotequote all
if you want a 1.6 and cheap insurance, i'd go for an earlier and lighter car. i.e. pre '94 mk1. depends if pop-up lights are a real turn off (tho you can easily mod them)

otherwise *personally* i'd try and hold out for a 1.8 mk2/2.5

Combover

3,009 posts

234 months

Monday 12th May 2008
quotequote all
I've got a Nevada.

I've had a Mk1 1.8 and Mk2 1.8iS previously. The Nevada is damn good in comparison and well worht the outlay, except the seats which aren't brilliant. I'd seriuosly recommend one, although if you're looking at a Mk2.5, i'd get the 1.8. thumbup

Edited by Combover on Monday 12th May 12:33

Borris-Bear

815 posts

252 months

Monday 12th May 2008
quotequote all
My wife has had a Nevada for the last 18 months or so (have to sell now due to company car rules!) its a great car we have both loved it especially in weather such as we've had recently.

Cant comment on the 1.6 as have never driven one but the 1.8 has plenty of power and pulls nicely.

Combover

3,009 posts

234 months

Monday 12th May 2008
quotequote all
Borris-Bear said:
Cant comment on the 1.6 as have never driven one but the 1.8 has plenty of power and pulls nicely.
I don't agree. The 1.8 has barely enough power for what it is. Iam of the opinion that while it does pull niceley, it doesn't pull enough. The engine is smooth and sounds pretty good, but is underpowered. The 1.6 would just be too slow. smile

Mr POD

5,153 posts

199 months

Monday 12th May 2008
quotequote all
skinny said:
if pop-up lights are a real turn off (tho you can easily mod them)
How ?

buccal

533 posts

199 months

Monday 12th May 2008
quotequote all
Combover said:
Borris-Bear said:
Cant comment on the 1.6 as have never driven one but the 1.8 has plenty of power and pulls nicely.
I don't agree. The 1.8 has barely enough power for what it is. Iam of the opinion that while it does pull niceley, it doesn't pull enough. The engine is smooth and sounds pretty good, but is underpowered. The 1.6 would just be too slow. smile
Both are slow IMHO. Sounds like insurance is the main issue. £400 extra for a 1.8 seems a lot

MX-5 Lazza

7,954 posts

226 months

Monday 12th May 2008
quotequote all
buccal said:
Combover said:
Borris-Bear said:
Cant comment on the 1.6 as have never driven one but the 1.8 has plenty of power and pulls nicely.
I don't agree. The 1.8 has barely enough power for what it is. Iam of the opinion that while it does pull niceley, it doesn't pull enough. The engine is smooth and sounds pretty good, but is underpowered. The 1.6 would just be too slow. smile
Both are slow IMHO. Sounds like insurance is the main issue. £400 extra for a 1.8 seems a lot
Depends what you compare it to, how you drive and what sort of driving you do.
As has been said many times before, these cars aren't about straight line speed - even a Gold TDI can match or even beat an MX-5 in a drag race but who cares? Where is the fun in that? Get it on a good twisty road and they won't see you for dust!

SiC2

Original Poster:

148 posts

212 months

Monday 12th May 2008
quotequote all
I know that it isnt going to be the quickest car in the world. I have a test drive booked for tomorrow in a 1.6 Nevada, I want something than i can have some fun in the bends and top down motoring. Does £8995 sound steep for a 1.6 Nevada with 38,000 miles and also from a Mazda main dealer (like the idea of the 12 month warrentee on it)

Combover

3,009 posts

234 months

Monday 12th May 2008
quotequote all
SiC2 said:
I know that it isnt going to be the quickest car in the world. I have a test drive booked for tomorrow in a 1.6 Nevada, I want something than i can have some fun in the bends and top down motoring. Does £8995 sound steep for a 1.6 Nevada with 38,000 miles and also from a Mazda main dealer (like the idea of the 12 month warrentee on it)
Yes. My 1.8 Nevada was damn near £2.5K less with ~30,000 miles.

MX-5 Lazza

7,954 posts

226 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
Yes that is a little expensive but probably about what you'd expect to pay from a main-dealer. It's better to look around at the private market as there are some real bargains out there. Don't worry too much about the warranty, if you can save £1000 and the worst happens the saving can pay for a new engine! They don't go wrong anyway, certainly not if you are looking at 3-4 year old cars.

jazzybee

3,056 posts

256 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
Sorry, I know all the talk is of a Mk2.5 Nevada, but just seen this very nice looking import in the classifieds and very reasonable price. Its a Mk2 1.8 RS import for £3895


MX-5 Lazza

7,954 posts

226 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
That does look very very nice biggrin

A couple of years ago I didn't like white MX-5s but they are really growing on me now to the point now where I would actively seek one out if I was looking for one now.

SiC2

Original Poster:

148 posts

212 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
That looks lovely - what is an RS model? Unfortunately i really need a car newer than X reg - (Have a personalised number plate that i want to keep on it)

I had a drive in a 1.6 Nevada today and wasnt particularly impressed with it, but think that may have been because i drove it in the middle of leicester so not ideal MX5 location. I felt that it lacked power especially in stop start traffic. Going to have a look at some more locally as country roads are closer to try them on.

MX-5 Lazza

7,954 posts

226 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
Remember though that with MX-5s most of the power is at higher revs, regardless of the engine. To make any sort of rapid progress you need to wring it's neck and thrash it's nuts off. If you drive around under 3krpm then it will feel slow. Over 4k and they start to come alive and over 6k they are really buzzing. Don't worry about the engines, you can't break them with revs.

pmanson

13,387 posts

260 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
jazzybee said:
Sorry, I know all the talk is of a Mk2.5 Nevada, but just seen this very nice looking import in the classifieds and very reasonable price. Its a Mk2 1.8 RS import for £3895

Yum!

That I like a lot. Although I would as this is ours:


skinny

5,269 posts

242 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
jazzybee said:
Sorry, I know all the talk is of a Mk2.5 Nevada, but just seen this very nice looking import in the classifieds and very reasonable price. Its a Mk2 1.8 RS import for £3895

very nice - very rare (import only) colour for the mk2 and looks great on the 2.5 wheels. good price too imo

as for modding pop-ups you can either get low pro conversion which pops them up to about half height and use either two small side by side lights on either side or rectangular lights, or you can get a flush conversion with a clear cover like the fiat coupe

pmanson

13,387 posts

260 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
skinny said:
as for modding pop-ups you can either get low pro conversion which pops them up to about half height and use either two small side by side lights on either side
Can you still get these? mmmm

Combover

3,009 posts

234 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
yes Try Moss-Parts.