M5 Gearboz am i the only one who hated it?

M5 Gearboz am i the only one who hated it?

Author
Discussion

lambo_xx

Original Poster:

2,199 posts

203 months

Saturday 14th June 2008
quotequote all
A few months back i had a M5 for a day and took it for a good thrash! Car was great loved the engine ect but that gearbox ruined it for me. I was considering buying an M6 but after driving that M5 gearbox i just couldn't live with it. I just felt it was slow and jerky at any speed other than full throttle. I's a shame because the gearbox ruins the car, but what i didn't get was anyone else i spoke to who had driven it loved the car and didn't mind the gearbox. Just wondering if anyone else agrees with me that the gearbox is s**t?

waremark

3,250 posts

219 months

Sunday 15th June 2008
quotequote all
Not the only one, I agree, and I have spoken to quite a few who were put off M3 CSL, M5 or M6 by the gearboxes. Have just got an M3 DCT which is completely different and very good.

Vixpy1

42,664 posts

270 months

Sunday 15th June 2008
quotequote all
I love the SMG type boxes, cannot stand the DSG box's fitted to the VAG cars, however have not tried the BMW twin clutch system yet.

Zod

35,295 posts

264 months

Sunday 15th June 2008
quotequote all
I ove the SMG box. I hope I won't hate the new DCT one. I hate most autos.

Harris_I

3,237 posts

265 months

Sunday 15th June 2008
quotequote all
I don't hate it, as I can't deny it's an incredible piece of technology.

However, it's taken away a crucial element of analogue control from the driver and dumbed down the overall experience. It's possible to smooth out the up-changes, but frankly not very satisfying.

As for reliability, I've had countless sensor warnings and a replaced transmission. In fact, my confidence in the system is now so low that as soon as the car is out of warranty, I will probably get rid. A shame, as the rest of the car is brilliant.

MitchT

16,167 posts

215 months

Sunday 15th June 2008
quotequote all
Ironically the M5 can be bought with a manual 'box in the US!

Zod

35,295 posts

264 months

Sunday 15th June 2008
quotequote all
It's OK to buy one. Ashok had all the bad ones. hehe