Track car oil ?

Author
Discussion

SBE46

Original Poster:

7 posts

49 months

Tuesday 27th October 2020
quotequote all
Hello good evening ....
I’m trying to do some research into the correct oil I should use in my 2000 e46 330ci I am in the camp of use standard grade and changing it often but after blowing the car up at the Nürburgring on the start finish straight I’m happy for someone to change my mind 😂
The car is a track day car used as on the road every now and again .
People’s opinions are greatly appreciated. 👍

Krikkit

27,000 posts

188 months

Tuesday 27th October 2020
quotequote all
Did you identify why it failed, or just ignore it? Any mods?

iguana

7,056 posts

267 months

Wednesday 28th October 2020
quotequote all
Always ran/run 5-40 fully synth in my e36s in M3 & 328 track forms, as has my pal in his 328s, between us hundreds of ring laps & thousands of track miles. I prefer to use shell helix, but not ever bought off ebay etc so much fake crap out there.

Others I know use 5-50 comma for bit more thickness when really hot & even 10-60 by a few manufacturers.

With the 36s & I bet the 46s too, the lesser non M models would benefit from an oil cooler, usually oil issues are simply the oil has got too hot, I replaced my track car oil coolers on the m3s for larger & better over oe.

brillomaster

1,398 posts

177 months

Wednesday 28th October 2020
quotequote all
Just a heads up, i killed an e46 330ci through lack of oil. Silly me thought that because the m52 engine in my 328i didnt use a drop of oil, the m54 engine in a 330ci would be the same. Turned out it was using a litre a day, died after 4 and a half days...

E-bmw

9,976 posts

159 months

Wednesday 28th October 2020
quotequote all
OK, but just because you lost an engine due to high oil use not noticed doesn't mean you need to use different oil, just that you need to keep an eye on usage.

untakenname

5,052 posts

199 months

Wednesday 28th October 2020
quotequote all
Often oil can shear down to a lower viscosity during heavy track use so it's best to change it for one of a higher viscosity.

I also use Shell Helix Ultra on track, some Ferrari owners in America have had used oil analysis done and the 10W60 will drop to 40 after less than 2000 miles.

Humour

297 posts

158 months

Wednesday 28th October 2020
quotequote all
The most slippery one you can find. There is a brand called Snake Oil. Give that a go.

mmm-five

11,443 posts

291 months

Wednesday 28th October 2020
quotequote all
Why did it 'blow up'.

If you missed a gear and blew it up, then different oil will not magically solve driving issues.

E-bmw

9,976 posts

159 months

Wednesday 28th October 2020
quotequote all
mmm-five said:
Why did it 'blow up'.

If you missed a gear and blew it up, then different oil will not magically solve driving issues.
He said it blew up because he didn't check the level & it was using lots, so blew up, hence my point a few posts above yours.

mmm-five

11,443 posts

291 months

Wednesday 28th October 2020
quotequote all
E-bmw said:
He said it blew up because he didn't check the level & it was using lots, so blew up, hence my point a few posts above yours.
I thought it was brillomaster who said that, not the OP who posted and left.

E-bmw

9,976 posts

159 months

Wednesday 28th October 2020
quotequote all
mmm-five said:
E-bmw said:
He said it blew up because he didn't check the level & it was using lots, so blew up, hence my point a few posts above yours.
I thought it was brillomaster who said that, not the OP who posted and left.
Good point. wink

SBE46

Original Poster:

7 posts

49 months

Wednesday 28th October 2020
quotequote all
Thanks for the replays people
The car is still in Germany so I have not had opportunity to strip the engine just a hunch oil temps have played a big part !
Driver error not at fault (this time)
Iv picked up an s54 oil filter housing and oil cooler today !

seabod91

691 posts

69 months

Wednesday 28th October 2020
quotequote all
I’m sure it’s actually common for the 330i e46 to have oil problems, if memory is right it’s due to the oil pump not being happy for prolonged high rpm stints. Also I’m sure there is an aftermarket solution ( uprated oil pump ).

SBE46

Original Poster:

7 posts

49 months

Wednesday 28th October 2020
quotequote all
I think you are correct in what you say they don’t like high revs for long periods of time.
I think I will wire the nut onto the oil pump on my new engine.

motorhole

678 posts

227 months

Thursday 29th October 2020
quotequote all
In pretty much anything but a highly modified race engine, my personal opinion is to pick an oil that meets all the manufacturers specifications and cool it so it runs within the intended temperature range.

Running a thicker oil is a sticking plaster solution really as the tolerances in the engine will be set based on the manufacturer recommended hot oil viscosity. Whilst after 15 mins on track at 120c the oil might be at the right viscosity, in any other situation it won't be.

I'm using Motul 8100 xcess 5w40 in my M52B30 engine - it meets BMW manufacturer specs as well as loads others. And it's high zinc content - not an issue for me as it's in an E30 without a cat. With a 16 row cooler, it doesn't exceed 110c on track, even on a 30c day. Changed every 4-5 trackdays, based on viscosity index & oxidation from used oil analysis. That's about 700 track miles and another 1k road miles or so at a guess.

Race cars you'll find tend to run thinner, not thicker oils. BTCC etc will mostly be running 5/30 or flat 30 weight. Engines built with tight tolerances for the thinner oil, cooled properly to remain in designed temperature range - and the thinner oil means less internal friction - more power.

Disclaimer - not an oil expert, just a layman having done a little bit of research having been told it wasn't worth running Motorsport oil in my track car biggrin

Krikkit

27,000 posts

188 months

Thursday 29th October 2020
quotequote all
SBE46 said:
I think you are correct in what you say they don’t like high revs for long periods of time.
I think I will wire the nut onto the oil pump on my new engine.
If it hadn't been done then it could very well be the oil pump, well-known flaw on the M54B30s.

Also worth removing the CCV and fitting a catch tank, as they often cause high oil usage.

SBE46

Original Poster:

7 posts

49 months

Thursday 29th October 2020
quotequote all
Dose anyone run a oil stat with there oil cooler ?
Are they necessary ?

motorhole

678 posts

227 months

Thursday 29th October 2020
quotequote all
SBE46 said:
Dose anyone run a oil stat with there oil cooler ?
Are they necessary ?
Yes - and if you're using the car as a road car too, yes again. Otherwise under normal driving it'll take ages for the engine to get up to temp. Alternatively you could run a removable blanking plate for the cooler I guess, just taking it off for trackdays. But a thermostat is the proper solution.

Humour

297 posts

158 months

Friday 30th October 2020
quotequote all
Krikkit said:
SBE46 said:
I think you are correct in what you say they don’t like high revs for long periods of time.
I think I will wire the nut onto the oil pump on my new engine.
If it hadn't been done then it could very well be the oil pump, well-known flaw on the M54B30s.
Not just the M54B30 but because of the long stroke coupled with an aluminium block, those are most susseptable, but the square M52B28's have also been known to implode when revved past 7.4Krpm consistently in standard guise.

The cabled nut is not a solution because the whole sprocket shaft is a weak link. Either fully replace the pump assembly with one developed to counter this issue (shaft/sprocket/multipoint foixngs), or buy an expensive ATI damper from the US to reduce harmonics at high rpm, or just dont rev the M54 past 6.5Krpm. It doesnt make much power beyond that in std. trim anyway.

Im still std setup in my M52B28 and taking a risk but dont rev the car past 7.2Krpm at all and knock on wood so far has been solid with over 5 years of TD only abuse.

Personally, I would use a B28 lump with M50 manifold and with some cams and exhaust you will be running above 230HP with a slightly more rev happy motor.

Peace.

iguana

7,056 posts

267 months

Friday 30th October 2020
quotequote all
Humour said:
Personally, I would use a B28 lump with M50 manifold and with some cams and exhaust you will be running above 230HP with a slightly more rev happy motor.
M3 headers give good gains, on a pretty conservative dyno & without cams but obvs the m50 inlet have seen in the 240s, mapping a must tho.