Change 1.6 civic diesel for 1.8 petrol

Change 1.6 civic diesel for 1.8 petrol

Author
Discussion

izzybella

Original Poster:

50 posts

76 months

Sunday 24th March 2019
quotequote all
Hi Guys,
We have been looking at a change of Civic we currently have a 2013 Civic 1.6 diesel with 70k on the clock full dealer service history but as we don't do the high mileage we bought the car for would it be a good idea to change up to a Civic EX with all whistle and bells, or stay with the diesel we have had and still get over 84mpg on a run and if driven like a granny I have had 98mpg (all be at about 2am on the motorway with no traffic to contend with) but 66mpg local driving town work.

What would if any benefits could we gain if we change to the 1.8 petrol. we have seen a rather nice 1.8 in sliver with low mileage.

rat840771

2,028 posts

172 months

Monday 8th April 2019
quotequote all
I’ve just got the latest 1.5 vtec turbo petrol and love it. The tech in the car is amazing. It basically drives itself

It’s the first petrol I’ve had for years. Cruising around 80 on long trip I averaged 48mpg. I’m happy with that! I understand that the 1.5 in the real world is better than the 1.0vtec. I’m sure the diesel would be better on fuel but it’s not as good to drive

adingley84

337 posts

169 months

Friday 12th April 2019
quotequote all
izzybella said:
Hi Guys,
We have been looking at a change of Civic we currently have a 2013 Civic 1.6 diesel with 70k on the clock full dealer service history but as we don't do the high mileage we bought the car for would it be a good idea to change up to a Civic EX with all whistle and bells, or stay with the diesel we have had and still get over 84mpg on a run and if driven like a granny I have had 98mpg (all be at about 2am on the motorway with no traffic to contend with) but 66mpg local driving town work.

What would if any benefits could we gain if we change to the 1.8 petrol. we have seen a rather nice 1.8 in sliver with low mileage.
Hold on a minute...98mpg...I cant believe that...downhill with wind behind my M135i gets 999mpg though so there

evsky

38 posts

133 months

Monday 15th April 2019
quotequote all
adingley84 said:
Hold on a minute...98mpg...I cant believe that...downhill with wind behind my M135i gets 999mpg though so there
https://www.autoexpress.co.uk/honda/civic/92127/honda-sets-new-efficiency-record-with-100mpg-civic-run

ninjag

1,874 posts

126 months

Tuesday 16th April 2019
quotequote all
izzybella said:
Hi Guys,
We have been looking at a change of Civic we currently have a 2013 Civic 1.6 diesel with 70k on the clock full dealer service history but as we don't do the high mileage we bought the car for would it be a good idea to change up to a Civic EX with all whistle and bells, or stay with the diesel we have had and still get over 84mpg on a run and if driven like a granny I have had 98mpg (all be at about 2am on the motorway with no traffic to contend with) but 66mpg local driving town work.

What would if any benefits could we gain if we change to the 1.8 petrol. we have seen a rather nice 1.8 in sliver with low mileage.
The 1.8 petrol is quite thirsty. Had to be pushed hard to get even a remote bit of fun out of it and bang goes your economy. I'd keep your diesel.

izzybella

Original Poster:

50 posts

76 months

Thursday 8th August 2019
quotequote all
yep 98 mpg I did stop as I came off the motorway to get photographic evidence but the police pulled up behind me and moved me on sorry I cannot prove it

izzybella

Original Poster:

50 posts

76 months

Thursday 8th August 2019
quotequote all
Well be bit the bullet and bought the Civic 1.8 SR auto full leather, sun roof, sat nav, heated seats, electric lumber adjustments rear tints, low profile tyres low mileage, full service history. In silver metallic. Loving it so far

Ballistic

956 posts

267 months

Sunday 11th August 2019
quotequote all
izzybella said:
Well be bit the bullet and bought the Civic 1.8 SR auto full leather, sun roof, sat nav, heated seats, electric lumber adjustments rear tints, low profile tyres low mileage, full service history. In silver metallic. Loving it so far
I'll be interested to hear how you get on with the 1.8 as I'm thinking of making the same change.

That sounds like a great spec car. How much did you get it for if you don't mind me asking?

izzybella

Original Poster:

50 posts

76 months

Friday 16th August 2019
quotequote all
Ballistic said:
izzybella said:
Well be bit the bullet and bought the Civic 1.8 SR auto full leather, sun roof, sat nav, heated seats, electric lumber adjustments rear tints, low profile tyres low mileage, full service history. In silver metallic. Loving it so far
I'll be interested to hear how you get on with the 1.8 as I'm thinking of making the same change.

That sounds like a great spec car. How much did you get it for if you don't mind me asking?
Hi I am very happy with the 1.8 engine plant coupled to Honda auto gearbox mpg could be better, but I knew that the mpg would be poor compared to the diesel what I find with Honda cars in general is the hard ride you feel all the bumps with low profile tyres but being an SR that's to be expected (bit sporty) I part ex my 62 plate 1.6 diesel civic so I guess I paid in the region of £11 k. My car was ex Honda and had 17825 miles from new so nearly run in.

beko1987

1,677 posts

141 months

Wednesday 6th November 2019
quotequote all
Interested to hear of your ownership experience with the diesel one tbh... Just this very morning I had a browse of potential new sheds as I sometimes do and tidy 2003/4 1.7 diesels (assuming that's 1698cc?) are £500 for a tidy one with sensible miles...

thatdude

2,658 posts

134 months

Friday 15th November 2019
quotequote all
I have a 1.8i with the 5 speed auto. fuel economy is around 42 mpg with my mixed commute driving, on a run I've comfortably obtained 45-46 mpg. The auto box is alright, but the gearing is quite looooooooonnnnng - second gear is a similar ratio to what third gear was in my old 1.6i civic sport. In any case, I got it because I wanted a car that was comparatively simple compared to more modern turbo charged units (the 1.8i engine is the R series which dates back to 2006 - my father has a 2006 civic with the same engine - manual transmission - and the engine is a peach).

It's not bad, it's pretty consistent with fuel economy albeit a bit of a lazy engine due to that gearing. I dont know how the 6-speed manuals are but they might be more fun to drive if the gearing is shorter in the lower gears.

izzybella

Original Poster:

50 posts

76 months

Friday 15th November 2019
quotequote all
beko1987 said:
Interested to hear of your ownership experience with the diesel one tbh... Just this very morning I had a browse of potential new sheds as I sometimes do and tidy 2003/4 1.7 diesels (assuming that's 1698cc?) are £500 for a tidy one with sensible miles...
Hi My car was a 10 plater Civic we found the car was the usual Honda comfort and reliability the engine had loads of torque and the fuel consumption was the best I have had better than the company cars I used to have (Ford Mondeo, S max and Vauxhall Zafira diesels) better by a long chalk I was continually getting high 70mpg and one occasion I did get 100 mpg bring like a granny on motorways.But got pulled by the police for that asking what was wrong,

thatdude

2,658 posts

134 months

Friday 22nd November 2019
quotequote all
izzybella said:
I did get 100 mpg bring like a granny on motorways.But got pulled by the police for that asking what was wrong,
Ummmm were you perhaps driving a bit slow?

Sometimes I se people on the motorway doing 50 mph (or less!) when there are not speed restrictions, it's a bit dangerous as it is a massive difference in speed.

Mind you, around 50 mph seems to the be optimum speed for max fuel efficiency in a honda. Used to get 50 mpg from my old 1.6 civic if I could sit at 50 mph

izzybella

Original Poster:

50 posts

76 months

Wednesday 27th November 2019
quotequote all
Hi I would only do that speed late at night no traffic and HGV could pass no problem my journey was north bound M6. M55. Usually my journeys on the motorway 65 mph seems a good cruising speed.