Is a 12 mile (24 round trip) commute too much?
Is a 12 mile (24 round trip) commute too much?
Author
Discussion

t84

Original Poster:

6,941 posts

223 months

Monday 19th April 2010
quotequote all
Looking at moving about 12 miles from my work, was just wondering if cycling this kind of distance 5 days a week would be suicide/horrible?

I am a newbie cyclist with a hardtail MTB smile

Thanks!

jodypress

2,102 posts

303 months

Monday 19th April 2010
quotequote all
totally doable. I would switch to road tyres on your MTB and then once you've built up some fitness, switch to a Hybrid or Road bike as they are better geared and more suited to road use.

Good luck and enjoy

Martyn-123

655 posts

214 months

Monday 19th April 2010
quotequote all
You will save loads of petrol money, no need to go to the gym anymore and will feel more awake when you get there. Consider putting on semi slicks or perhaps buy a road bike as well on the cycle to work scheme which has some great incentives,

Just ordered me a specialized crosstrail on this scheme and saved me over £250


Martyn....

t84

Original Poster:

6,941 posts

223 months

Monday 19th April 2010
quotequote all
Thanks, It's 4.3 miles from home to work at the moment which from a fitness perspective doesn't seem worth the hassle...

TwistingMyMelon

6,506 posts

234 months

Monday 19th April 2010
quotequote all
Mine is 13 miles each way , done it on a mtb on slicks as well in past

I would say upto 20 miles each way is fine , any more for me and it just takes too long every day (not just riding but prep time as well)

dubbs

1,599 posts

313 months

Monday 19th April 2010
quotequote all
mine is 26-27miles each way and it's no problem once you get used to it.

3-4 times a week I tend to aim for, start doing it around early March (end Feb this year) at twice a week then build up to 4 times a week.

You can do 5 but I like to have 1-2 weekdays to do other things plus need to fit in running/gym.

Allblackdup

3,312 posts

237 months

Monday 19th April 2010
quotequote all
Martyn-123 said:
Just ordered me a specialized crosstrail on this scheme and saved me over £250

Martyn....
Sorry to hijack - What Crosstrail did you go for?

I've got my search down to either the Crosstrail Sport or the Expert now. Be interested to hear which you chose and why?

raf_gti

4,253 posts

235 months

Monday 19th April 2010
quotequote all
dubbs said:
mine is 26-27miles each way and it's no problem once you get used to it.

3-4 times a week I tend to aim for, start doing it around early March (end Feb this year) at twice a week then build up to 4 times a week.

You can do 5 but I like to have 1-2 weekdays to do other things plus need to fit in running/gym.
Ditto.

I try and ride in on Monday, Tuesday and Thursday with a decent ride on Saturday as well.

I started last year driving in with bike then riding home, riding in next day driving home etc etc.

If you have locker space at work I'd recommend taking all your clothes in in a oner and keeping your on bike load to a minimum.

I'd love to live 12-15 miles from work!!

snotrag

15,624 posts

240 months

Monday 19th April 2010
quotequote all
Same distance as my commute.

My route is about 75% Tarmac, 25% off road. I do it on a nice XC hardtail with some low knob tyres. I could do it with thin slick but then the off-road bits wouldnt be as fun.

Few decent gradients, takes me 50 minutes, PB is 46. Thats a pretty good average.

I would say - I'm a pretty epxerience/strong cyclist - and 5 days a week is possible (ive done it) but thats a few chunk of miles, you'll feel it.

dont plan on 5 days from the off - start with 2 or 3 - Monday Weds Friday would be nice.

Also bear in mind that if your doing 120 miles a week your bike will need regular tlc.

97BlackC5

357 posts

267 months

Tuesday 20th April 2010
quotequote all
That is my distance aswell, all road (although the state of some of the roads, it might aswell be off-road) average time 48mins. If you plan to cycle everyday, you will feel it, just remember to save your legs, don't go trying to break any pb's on a Monday as you still have 4 more days to cycle. I've been doing this for about 6 years now & have been knocked once. Best advice is 'don't be in a hurry' & you will be fine.

t84

Original Poster:

6,941 posts

223 months

Tuesday 20th April 2010
quotequote all
97BlackC5 said:
That is my distance aswell, all road (although the state of some of the roads, it might aswell be off-road) average time 48mins. If you plan to cycle everyday, you will feel it, just remember to save your legs, don't go trying to break any pb's on a Monday as you still have 4 more days to cycle. I've been doing this for about 6 years now & have been knocked once. Best advice is 'don't be in a hurry' & you will be fine.
What's a PB? I got a Rockhopper from Ride2Work and that's all paid off so I could probably wangle a road bike in there as well smile

97BlackC5

357 posts

267 months

Tuesday 20th April 2010
quotequote all
'Personal Best' ...time...

t84

Original Poster:

6,941 posts

223 months

Tuesday 20th April 2010
quotequote all
Ah I see biggrin I won't be doing that anytime soon!

Chris71

21,549 posts

271 months

Tuesday 20th April 2010
quotequote all
Possibly hard work at first, but it'd be quite easy once you got into it, particularly with the right bike.

I'm a complete slob with a significant beer belly and a fairly heavy MTB-style hybird, yet I'm still just getting warmed up when my hilly 7.5 mile commute ends (takes about 25 minutes). Okay, it's not 12 miles, but I mention it because it proves you don't have to be a Lycra-clad stick insect straddling something made of carbon fibre and sipping on a protein shake! smile

anonymous-user

83 months

Tuesday 20th April 2010
quotequote all
I found my 8 miles took well under 30 mins, so not really challenging from a fitness perspective. Sometimes I did a detour via a nicer route that extended it to 10, 12 or 16 miles, I'd say anything around 45mins to an 1hr would be a perfect time/distance for fitness and not too far.

So I think you've got an ideal distance but the route could be tricky on a bike (ie. dual carriageways etc.). As others have said build up to it and certainly don't feel pressurized to do 5 out of 5.

Guys who used to do longer commutes than me used to drive in on Monday drop all their office stuff off for the week and then cycle Tues - Fri.

t84

Original Poster:

6,941 posts

223 months

Tuesday 20th April 2010
quotequote all
It'd be Warrington to Liverpool Airport area, I think the Transpennine Trail runs from there which I could look at taking, not sure how safe it is though, LOL!

superlightr

12,920 posts

292 months

Tuesday 20th April 2010
quotequote all
great topic.

Have a 15 mile drive to work but often will cycle 14 miles 2 or 3 times a week in the morning for fun !

Will have a bash as the cycle to work soon. Just not so keen on the busy roads.

DrMekon

2,493 posts

245 months

Tuesday 20th April 2010
quotequote all
Mine is 16.5 miles each way at the mo, albeit I vary the route and I tend to take detours (18.5 this morning). I am aiming for 6000 miles this year. That distance is perfect for me, as I can justify an hour commuting.

I'd say def get some slicks.

t84

Original Poster:

6,941 posts

223 months

Tuesday 20th April 2010
quotequote all
I have some slicks, but I put my knobblies back on because I go to Llandegla when I can with my girlfriend.

Hmm, justification for a 2nd bike? biggrin

r-kid

850 posts

216 months

Tuesday 20th April 2010
quotequote all
Mine is the same distance & like already been said its very doabe. It takes me about 40-45 minutes usually.