When flat pedals and Cleats fell in love...

When flat pedals and Cleats fell in love...

Author
Discussion

Gingerbread Man

Original Poster:

9,173 posts

220 months

Thursday 1st November 2007
quotequote all
...and had a baby. What I mean by this is those flat pedals with cleats/ Cleated pedals that you can ride without being clipped in.

I've always been tempted to splash on them, but never have thinking I'd hate the things. So who uses them and for what type of riding? I don't do as much riding as I used to now everyone went to uni and I can't do anything on my wink

I'd like to get back into/ into some single track, downhill - technical but not world class.

I'd keep my flats for when I need them.

Here are a few to get you thinking.













So now you know what I mean, tell me what you know about them. I want to be able to get in and out of them quickly and easily. I want them to deliver. If they are more of a gimic then put me in my place.

David

WildCards

4,061 posts

224 months

Thursday 1st November 2007
quotequote all
The top ones are Time, second and last picture are SPD's and the third picture are Crank brothers.

The time ones are your best option, followed by the SPD's. I se SPD's and get on well with them, easy in and out and don't clog too badly. Time pedals are sposed to be even better though, I've used them, liked them and would recommend them.

_daveR

6,146 posts

234 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all
If you actually try to use some Crank Bros Mallets as flat pedals you will. quite quickly, realise they are crap!

The cleat does not sit any where near flat enough to the body so your shoe will just slide around on it.

Either get clips of flats. Something that does both just wont work.

Kermit power

29,468 posts

220 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all
I have a set of Shimano pedals on my mountain bike which are SPD on one side, but on the other have a raised ridge which means the SPD gubbins sit out of the way. One way up, it's a flat, the other it's SPD. Quite handy when you want to mosey off to the pub without having to change shoes when you get there.

pdV6

16,442 posts

268 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all
WildCards said:
The top ones are Time
Nah - they're Atomlab

These are the Times:


mk1fan

10,648 posts

232 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all
Holy re-post Batman, if only there was a way to see the threads from last week.

I run Mallets and hven't had any problems. They're not as good as flats with pins but then again neither are those mentioned.

The next generation of Mallets will have pins instead of plates, though their release date is unkown to me.

Gingerbread Man

Original Poster:

9,173 posts

220 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all
mk1fan said:
boocks about reposting...

I run Mallets and hven't had any problems. They're not as good as flats with pins but then again neither are those mentioned.

The next generation of Mallets will have pins instead of plates, though their release date is unkown to me.
Do you use the mallets for every aspect of riding or do you chop and change?

And I hope for the sake of having the best, they are the magnesium version...?

mk1fan

10,648 posts

232 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all
Gingerbread Man said:
Bo%*%£ks about not being bothered to read previous threads.
I have been using Eggbeaters for four odd years (I had previusly been using SPD's). Swapping them between my S-Ws and my Stiffee. My riding had mainly been XC. In the last year my riding has started to be more and more Trail orientated and my trip to Morzine really highlighted the problems with small clip pedals. There were times when I wanted to just be on the pedals and not clipped in and the Eggbeaters just don't give you this option. Therefore I got a set of Mallets. The Eggbeaters now reside on my S-Ws and the Mallets stay on my Stiffee. As for chopping and changing, well I ride the Stiffee in my Northwave flat shoes and my Spesh clip shoes with no problems.

My Mallets are the Cromo version as my Stiffee isn't meant to be a lightweight XC speed machine, that's the job of the S-Ws.

Gingerbread Man

Original Poster:

9,173 posts

220 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all
So you'd recommend Mallets?

I guess I will have to look into buying some shoes and some pedals to try out. Try XC first and work my way to hard things?

David


mk1fan

10,648 posts

232 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all
Yes, I would recommend the Mallets for Trail riding. It would be worth reading this thread as shoes were mentioned too; http://www.pistonheads.co.uk/gassing/topic.asp?h=0...

It all comes down to personal taste though. If you're starting out and haven't riden clipless pedals previously then it might be worth starting off with a pair of DMR V8's or similar. Before progressing on to clipless. You never know you may find platform pedals are all you need.

One tip Platform pedals are best used with a flexible soled shoe (like a skateboarding shoe) whereas clipless (SPD's etc..) work best with a rigid soled cycling shoe.

Happy riding.

mk1fan

10,648 posts

232 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all
I would add that if you're starting off doing just XC then going straight to clipless is fine, and if you're running a dedicated mtb only bike then there's no need to run dual purpose pedals.

MTB skills are best learnt on flats though. So you can't cheat!

I have ridden most of the difficult trails in the Welsh centers and Morzine on my 'beaters without issue. But I'm moving away from XC into more Trail stuff (small drops and jumps, light freeriding etc..).

It's a hard call 'cause my approach is to buy what is right for me now and not consider what I may be doing in two years time. The expense isn't an issue to me. To others it might.

Edited by mk1fan on Friday 2nd November 18:00

Gingerbread Man

Original Poster:

9,173 posts

220 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all
I've currently riding with flats. Just posted my bike in the 'show off your bike' thread. I've just always been tempted by clipped pedals. I guess it's something I've never done and thus want to do.

mk1fan

10,648 posts

232 months

Sunday 4th November 2007
quotequote all
Just seen it. Hmmm another member of the PH's Cove family. NICE!

I'd say give the Mallets (or any of the other clipless systems) a try. It does mean an outlay of 150 notes but it will be the only way to find out if they're for you.

There's always eBay if you don't get on with them!

190Evoluzione

124 posts

206 months

Sunday 4th November 2007
quotequote all
I find my SPD-M540s easy to ride in non-SPD shoes for the pub run or popping out to a meeting
with 'normal clothes' on... Sure you can't put as much power through them, but tbh it's only the
odd fairly relaxed journey where I don't wear the Sidis.

About £30 iirc, and damn good spuds.