Hybrid bike for commuting / exercise

Hybrid bike for commuting / exercise

Author
Discussion

shouldbworking

Original Poster:

4,772 posts

217 months

Thursday 16th November 2006
quotequote all
I am after a bike for commuting and exercise, but my knowledge of bikes is quite nastily limited.

I had a look in a local cycle store and they had the dawes discovery range which seemed to fit the bill (specifically the 301), but I spoke to a friend who is into his bikes and he was suggesting that anything less than 500 quid would have compromises in its components that would mean it would be extremely unreliable. He pointed me at merlin cycles.

I suspect that he might be overblowing it a bit, or is it really the case that 90% of bikes ive seen sold in shops are unreliable trash?

Criteria -
less than £300
frame that weighs less than a ton
not excessively complicated (e.g. v-brakes not discs)
potential for expansion in the future (e.g. change of forks and wheels would make it passable off roads)

Thanks in advance

PH5121

1,974 posts

218 months

Thursday 16th November 2006
quotequote all
Why not get a mountain bike and put road tyres on it for the commute, rather than use a hybrid off road.
There have been threads on here before recommending mountain bikes in your price range, do a search and see what it brings up.

3rtt

943 posts

257 months

Thursday 16th November 2006
quotequote all
shouldbworking said:
I am after a bike for commuting and exercise, but my knowledge of bikes is quite nastily limited.

I had a look in a local cycle store and they had the dawes discovery range which seemed to fit the bill (specifically the 301), but I spoke to a friend who is into his bikes and he was suggesting that anything less than 500 quid would have compromises in its components that would mean it would be extremely unreliable. He pointed me at merlin cycles.

I suspect that he might be overblowing it a bit, or is it really the case that 90% of bikes ive seen sold in shops are unreliable trash?

Criteria -
less than £300
frame that weighs less than a ton
not excessively complicated (e.g. v-brakes not discs)
potential for expansion in the future (e.g. change of forks and wheels would make it passable off roads)

Thanks in advance


Try this from SCOTT. Sportster P5 RRP £279

www.scottusa.com/product.php?UID=9782

or Sub 30 RRP £329

www.scottusa.com/product.php?UID=9788

Cheers,
Ian.

shouldbworking

Original Poster:

4,772 posts

217 months

Thursday 16th November 2006
quotequote all
PH5121 said:
Why not get a mountain bike and put road tyres on it for the commute, rather than use a hybrid off road.


The primary use of it would be a road bike so id rather it was biased that way than for offroad.

ps. thanks for the suggestions. I will search through existing threads. Are scott bikes available through uk retailers?

Edited by shouldbworking on Thursday 16th November 16:58

beyond rational

3,527 posts

220 months

Thursday 16th November 2006
quotequote all
It might be worth looking at the specialized hardrock range, I always found them to offer a good quality frame and reasonable spec.

sjg

7,512 posts

270 months

Friday 17th November 2006
quotequote all
Kona Smoke.

www.konabikes.co.uk/2k7bikes/smoke_2k7.php

Hardly seems to have changed this year, so worth seeing if you can get a good deal on an 06 model.

Essentially it's a classic, old-school Kona mountain bike - steel, rigid fork, v-brakes, all good reliable stuff. Comes set up for commuting on with mudguards and slick tyres, but take those off and put some off-road tyres on and it'll be great on mud too (most people riding MTBs 10 years were on something very similar!). Could even stick a budget suspension fork on there later if you wanted.

They're ace - I've recommended them to a few people and all are very happy with them.

3rtt

943 posts

257 months

Friday 17th November 2006
quotequote all
shouldbworking said:
PH5121 said:
Why not get a mountain bike and put road tyres on it for the commute, rather than use a hybrid off road.


The primary use of it would be a road bike so id rather it was biased that way than for offroad.

ps. thanks for the suggestions. I will search through existing threads. Are scott bikes available through uk retailers?

Edited by shouldbworking on Thursday 16th November 16:58


SCOTT Bikes are available through UK retailers. There is a Dealer locator on there website:

www.scottusa.com/dealers/

Cheers,
Ian.

greatgranny

9,262 posts

231 months

Friday 17th November 2006
quotequote all
There's nothing wrong with a hybrid for road use and buying from a local shop is a good idea especially if you have any problems. A £500 bike would be overkill and the gearing on a mountain bike is too low for continuous road use. If the local shop seems ok go with their advise.