Joe Calzaghe, our man.

Joe Calzaghe, our man.

Author
Discussion

dr.sickman

Original Poster:

5,006 posts

228 months

Sunday 20th April 2008
quotequote all
What is the consensus on this man's status in UK and world boxing histories?

Mattt

16,663 posts

224 months

Sunday 20th April 2008
quotequote all
He won, so he's British and people are proud.

If he lost last night, he would have been Welsh.

vonhosen

40,429 posts

223 months

Sunday 20th April 2008
quotequote all
dr.sickman said:
What is the consensus on this man's status in UK and world boxing histories?
If he beats Jones it will result in legend status.

Robatr0n

12,362 posts

222 months

Sunday 20th April 2008
quotequote all
Mattt said:
He won, so he's British and people are proud.

If he lost last night, he would have been Welsh.
hehe

It's funny because as a boxing fan I have never preferred a boxer due to his nationality but instead for his ability.

I've been a calazghe fan long before he beat Eubank all those years ago so I was still awake at a stupid hour this morning to cheer him on.

Anyway, Joe Calzaghe should finally have earnt the respect he rightly deserves from anyone who is interested in boxing from the world over.

anonymous-user

60 months

Sunday 20th April 2008
quotequote all
To be fair it was a poor fight, he looked very unconvincing, almost amature at times.
Would have been great to show the yanks what he could really do.

juice

8,772 posts

288 months

Sunday 20th April 2008
quotequote all
Bandit said:
To be fair it was a poor fight, he looked very unconvincing, almost amature at times.
Would have been great to show the yanks what he could really do.
It was obvious (to me anyway) that hopkins was runing out of steam in the later rounds. No sour grapes, because JC won, but I have to say the "low" blow was at a fortuitous time and it was amazing for someone so supposededly so debilitated by that blow to come back after a 2 minute "breather" and nearly steal the round...But I suppose you don't get to be multiple world champion without learning a few tricks wink

I was watching it on HBO (US channel) and the commentators were adamant that Calzaghe won and did more than enough to secure victory. I thin he's come out of the fight with a lot more respect in the US now.

Robatr0n

12,362 posts

222 months

Sunday 20th April 2008
quotequote all
Bandit said:
To be fair it was a poor fight, he looked very unconvincing, almost amature at times.
Would have been great to show the yanks what he could really do.
The same could be said for any of the top fighters who have fought Hopkins. That is Bernards game, he rough houses people by way of illegal moves and constant clinching whilst backing up for most of the fight and attempting to counter.

Calzaghe is the only guy to have ever hit Hopkins that many times in any fight and even though they weren't hard hits they still counted and helped him win.

He will be able to show the 'yanks' exactly what he is made of when he fights someone who isn't scared of throwing some leather along with some power shots, i.e. Roy Jones or Kelly Pavlik if he comes up to 168 and Joe drops down to 168 to fight him.

I think alot of people seem to miss the fact that Hopkins, even at the age of 43, is still a living legend and hardly any of the top guys over in the states want to fight him.

Well done Joe! clap

The_Jackal

4,854 posts

203 months

Monday 21st April 2008
quotequote all
The thing is these days, fights at the top level are becoming more and more scrappy as people try to hang onto titles.
At the end of the day it is results that count.

The days of fights like Hagler, Hearns, Eubanks, McGuigan, McKenzie etc are few and far between these days. There is so much ducking and diving these days. When guys have to wait for so long for a fight that earns them their first million, all they are bothered about is standing up at the end (if they dont get knocked out in the first round) to claim their takings.

Whether or not JC fought his best fight doesnt matter, he took some so called hard punches to the head from Hopkins, as well as dragging his arse off the floor in the first round, and still won. You gotta be proud of the man Welsh or British. Just imagine if he had turned round and said "I aint gonna be beaten by a black man". He should have punched his nuts up into his throat for that comment.

RWA28

703 posts

230 months

Monday 21st April 2008
quotequote all
The_Jackal said:
"I aint gonna be beaten by a black man". He should have punched his nuts up into his throat for that comment.
Too right.

RWA28

703 posts

230 months

Monday 21st April 2008
quotequote all
Mattt said:
He won, so he's British and people are proud.

If he lost last night, he would have been Welsh.
What's that meant to mean? Surely that's a similar comment to what Hopkins said isn't it?

anonymous-user

60 months

Monday 21st April 2008
quotequote all
juice said:
Bandit said:
To be fair it was a poor fight, he looked very unconvincing, almost amature at times.
Would have been great to show the yanks what he could really do.
It was obvious (to me anyway) that hopkins was runing out of steam in the later rounds. No sour grapes, because JC won, but I have to say the "low" blow was at a fortuitous time and it was amazing for someone so supposededly so debilitated by that blow to come back after a 2 minute "breather" and nearly steal the round...But I suppose you don't get to be multiple world champion without learning a few tricks wink

I was watching it on HBO (US channel) and the commentators were adamant that Calzaghe won and did more than enough to secure victory. I thin he's come out of the fight with a lot more respect in the US now.
I dunno, he just seemed amature, kept getting picked off, left his guard down, lost control of his aggression at the end of several rounds which could have cost him..... and my biggest gripe was his handbag type bh slapping during mid to late rounds, what was all that about? 6/10 from me, could have done better !

The_Jackal

4,854 posts

203 months

Monday 21st April 2008
quotequote all
The thing is, if Hopkins had won he wouldn't have been able to hold his head up high saying he fought a good fight either would he?

Did anyone else think judge number 1 had been paid off? They weren't exactly consistent scores were they lol

dr.sickman

Original Poster:

5,006 posts

228 months

Monday 21st April 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
dr.sickman said:
What is the consensus on this man's status in UK and world boxing histories?
If he beats Jones it will result in legend status.
This is a strong opinion. Not that I disagree. It seems though that this status is not clear cut: has boxing been too dirtied in general, or is there something about him that isn't quite legend material?

scorp

8,783 posts

235 months

Monday 21st April 2008
quotequote all
dr.sickman said:
vonhosen said:
dr.sickman said:
What is the consensus on this man's status in UK and world boxing histories?
If he beats Jones it will result in legend status.
This is a strong opinion. Not that I disagree. It seems though that this status is not clear cut: has boxing been too dirtied in general, or is there something about him that isn't quite legend material?
There's nothing to be gained by beating an faded glass-chinned Jones. Joe is an awesome fighter but I can't help but feel he had been protected most his career.

Alex

9,975 posts

290 months

Monday 21st April 2008
quotequote all
scorp said:
There's nothing to be gained by beating an faded glass-chinned Jones. Joe is an awesome fighter but I can't help but feel he had been protected most his career.
He's not so much been protected, as avoided.

scorp

8,783 posts

235 months

Monday 21st April 2008
quotequote all
Alex said:
scorp said:
There's nothing to be gained by beating an faded glass-chinned Jones. Joe is an awesome fighter but I can't help but feel he had been protected most his career.
He's not so much been protected, as avoided.
Frank Warren is notorious for protecting his fighters and Calzaghes record is full of no-names, i can't imagine history will look too kind on that.

Simpo Two

86,761 posts

271 months

Monday 21st April 2008
quotequote all
RWA28 said:
The_Jackal said:
"I aint gonna be beaten by a black man". He should have punched his nuts up into his throat for that comment.
Too right.
Go for it.

But would you be so upset if the black guy had said 'I ain't gonna be beaten by a white man'?

I guess not.

Mattygooner

5,301 posts

210 months

Monday 21st April 2008
quotequote all
Joe is already a legend, there is a difference between protected and avoided. He has some big names on his list, and destroyed alot of them, this was not vintage Joe, but he had to adapt and overcome wich he did. Hopkins sat bank and clinched whenever he could, was good in close as well, which is funny as the Ref allowed it but not when Hatton did it....strange, also some shocking un punished head action from Hopkins.

The fact remains, Joe was the agressor for 90% of the fight, away from home and against someone of Hopkins Calibre, that is quite impressive. By no means was not his best display but he did what he needed to.

The_Jackal

4,854 posts

203 months

Monday 21st April 2008
quotequote all
Simpo, he (BH) actually DID say "he aint gonna be beat by no white man".

Only half my posted was quoted. What I was saying, was can you imagine the trouble JC would be in if HE had said "I aint gonna be beat by no black man".

Robatr0n

12,362 posts

222 months

Monday 21st April 2008
quotequote all
scorp said:
Alex said:
scorp said:
There's nothing to be gained by beating an faded glass-chinned Jones. Joe is an awesome fighter but I can't help but feel he had been protected most his career.
He's not so much been protected, as avoided.
Frank Warren is notorious for protecting his fighters and Calzaghes record is full of no-names, i can't imagine history will look too kind on that.
Yes Frank Warren does protect fighters but surely the fact that a prime Jones Jnr opted out of fighting Calzaghe and a younger Hopkins also avoided Calzaghe years ago must tell you something?

I still maintain that Mikkel Kessler could take a trip over to the states and give a good few of the top guys a royal roughing up.

At the moment I don't see Dawson, Tarver or Jones beating Calzaghe, although Jones won't be easy as he is also lightning quick, packs a punch and has the reactions of a Cat! hehe