JCW Hatchback Auto

JCW Hatchback Auto

Author
Discussion

milob5914

Original Poster:

9 posts

92 months

Monday 3rd September 2018
quotequote all
Morning Guys,

I am looking at purchasing a JCW Auto. I drive to and from work for 40 mins each way. What is it like on fuel and how much to fill up a tank?

Any help would be useful!

Thanks!

pb8g09

2,688 posts

76 months

Monday 3rd September 2018
quotequote all
About £46 to fill a tank at 127p a litre- though you ought to be putting the good stuff in so probably closer to £60.

Depends how you drive for MPG - 36mpg if you drive like a granny, 23mpg if you drive like a hooligan.

Edit - Assuming you're driving mixed/clearer roads, not sat in stationary traffic

milob5914

Original Poster:

9 posts

92 months

Monday 3rd September 2018
quotequote all
Perfect, thank you for this. Very helpful!

Apparently they have stopped production. Is this a bad thing to buy a used 18 plate now?

Miles

pb8g09

2,688 posts

76 months

Monday 3rd September 2018
quotequote all
milob5914 said:
Perfect, thank you for this. Very helpful!

Apparently they have stopped production. Is this a bad thing to buy a used 18 plate now?

Miles
Production stop was because of the ongoing WLTP emissions. Wouldn't surprise me if this is the last hardcore version of a mass produced JCW.

Personally (completely subjective and not based on any facts) I'd argue that now would be the best time to grab one before the new model is tweaked following the above. I was set to get one 3 weeks ago but ended up getting an Audi S1 (I thought it was a bit less shouty and I'm dull).

I have noticed that if you're getting from a main dealer, the really push for the hard sale closer to end of quarter (even more so than other dealers) so perhaps make the most of that.



GT4P

5,402 posts

192 months

Monday 3rd September 2018
quotequote all
Not just wltp but also from the 01.09.18 all petrol engines to be fitted with particulate filter to exhaust which is reducing power on some models, plus with the WLTP is killing some models off!
Personally grab yourself a delivery miles 18 plate could be the last decent JCW

milob5914

Original Poster:

9 posts

92 months

Monday 3rd September 2018
quotequote all
Thanks Guys,

So the thought is, grab one now.

I was offered an 18 plate on delivery miles, its their demo but nice spec!

Have a 435d M Sport now but its too big and im getting screwed by having a diesel and with the low emissions coming in, it will screw me more!

M

pb8g09

2,688 posts

76 months

Monday 3rd September 2018
quotequote all
milob5914 said:
Thanks Guys,

So the thought is, grab one now.

I was offered an 18 plate on delivery miles, its their demo but nice spec!

Have a 435d M Sport now but its too big and im getting screwed by having a diesel and with the low emissions coming in, it will screw me more!

M
Do it, you won't regret it - will put big smiles on your face compared to the 435d!

milob5914

Original Poster:

9 posts

92 months

Monday 3rd September 2018
quotequote all
Im considering. Is the Auto just as good? Hate Manual and refuse to get back into one!

pb8g09

2,688 posts

76 months

Monday 3rd September 2018
quotequote all
I drove the auto and it made all the pops and crackles on the gear change which when test driving I thought was hilarious and put a big grin on my face.

However I have also just bought a house on a quiet street and I didn't want to p*ss off my new neighbours driving out to work at 7am so figured the novelty may wear off!

I ended up buying a manual car because I think it makes better for when you are 'having a moment' and want to get to the speed limit as fast as you can from the lights but then drop out into a higher gear when you're there but I appreciate my other half's auto when lazy driving around town.

Every review I read seemed to suggest the manual JCW is better than the auto.

milob5914

Original Poster:

9 posts

92 months

Monday 3rd September 2018
quotequote all
Appreciate the help!

Selling my 435d if anyone is interested!

mh125

79 posts

81 months

Tuesday 4th September 2018
quotequote all
Only driven an auto countryman Cooper s 18 plate as a loaner. I was disappointed it was only 5 speed that seems a dated to me when rivals offer 7/8 etc.

Maracus

4,476 posts

175 months

Tuesday 4th September 2018
quotequote all
mh125 said:
Only driven an auto countryman Cooper s 18 plate as a loaner. I was disappointed it was only 5 speed that seems a dated to me when rivals offer 7/8 etc.
That will more likely be the Aisin 6 speed auto.

I find it ok in our R56 Cooper S.

amare32

2,419 posts

230 months

Tuesday 4th September 2018
quotequote all
I bought an auto JCW on a June '17 plate with 5k miles back in May for £13k less than list stuffed full of options. Considered a manual but as my commute is mostly made up of gridlocked traffic 70% of the time, I decided semi-auto was the best of both worlds as I can stick it on Sport + manual box mode whenever I go for a spirited drive. The car also came with an extended TLC running till 2021 and warranty will 2020. I believe MINI no longer offer extended TLC post September '17.

Didn't go for the JCW Pro Exhaust as the loud pops and bangs would pi55 everyone off. The standard exhaust in Sport mode stills pops a bit.

The car is an absolute hoot to drive. I had looked at a 435d but after trying out the JCW, I had so much fun that it was a no brainer - especially on the right B road.

stock runflat tyres are a bit skittish so once I've worn through these, I'll stick some Michellin Pilots for improved grip and less road noise.

I don't do many miles so normally put in £30 petrol a week - 22mpg when pushing it which is reasonable.

Go for it I'd say smile




pb8g09

2,688 posts

76 months

Tuesday 4th September 2018
quotequote all
amare32 said:
I bought an auto JCW on a June '17 plate with 5k miles back in May for £13k less than list stuffed full of options. Considered a manual but as my commute is mostly made up of gridlocked traffic 70% of the time, I decided semi-auto was the best of both worlds as I can stick it on Sport + manual box mode whenever I go for a spirited drive. The car also came with an extended TLC running till 2021 and warranty will 2020. I believe MINI no longer offer extended TLC post September '17.

Didn't go for the JCW Pro Exhaust as the loud pops and bangs would pi55 everyone off. The standard exhaust in Sport mode stills pops a bit.

The car is an absolute hoot to drive. I had looked at a 435d but after trying out the JCW, I had so much fun that it was a no brainer - especially on the right B road.

stock runflat tyres are a bit skittish so once I've worn through these, I'll stick some Michellin Pilots for improved grip and less road noise.

I don't do many miles so normally put in £30 petrol a week - 22mpg when pushing it which is reasonable.

Go for it I'd say smile
Out of curiosity, how often do you use the paddles?


anonymous-user

61 months

Tuesday 4th September 2018
quotequote all
I have an auto cooper s on a 67 plate and it is pretty thirsty. On a run you can get 35ish though.

I use the paddles quite a bit they are good fun and if you put the car and gearbox in sport it is v fast.

Get yourself a remap for even more hokum.

amare32

2,419 posts

230 months

Tuesday 4th September 2018
quotequote all
pb8g09 said:
amare32 said:
I bought an auto JCW on a June '17 plate with 5k miles back in May for £13k less than list stuffed full of options. Considered a manual but as my commute is mostly made up of gridlocked traffic 70% of the time, I decided semi-auto was the best of both worlds as I can stick it on Sport + manual box mode whenever I go for a spirited drive. The car also came with an extended TLC running till 2021 and warranty will 2020. I believe MINI no longer offer extended TLC post September '17.

Didn't go for the JCW Pro Exhaust as the loud pops and bangs would pi55 everyone off. The standard exhaust in Sport mode stills pops a bit.

The car is an absolute hoot to drive. I had looked at a 435d but after trying out the JCW, I had so much fun that it was a no brainer - especially on the right B road.

stock runflat tyres are a bit skittish so once I've worn through these, I'll stick some Michellin Pilots for improved grip and less road noise.

I don't do many miles so normally put in £30 petrol a week - 22mpg when pushing it which is reasonable.

Go for it I'd say smile
Out of curiosity, how often do you use the paddles?
I’d say 30% of my driving I use the paddles. The box is a pretty good auto box but surprising both upshifts and downshifts is very smooth and dare I’d say better than Audi S-Tronic box. Maybe not quite DCT levels but pretty darn good. Highly recommended.

anonymous-user

61 months

Saturday 8th September 2018
quotequote all
Oh and don't forget to turn traction control off fully by holding the switch for a few seconds. It's a whole different car.

GiveItSomeWellie

3,040 posts

203 months

Tuesday 25th September 2018
quotequote all
I've driven the 8 speed in Cooper S LCI form, and the older 6 speed in Cooper form, so not a direct comparison.

The 8 speed is a huge improvement over the 6 speed, which to be fair was a fairly good base to start with. However the 8 speed always seemed to be one step ahead of your own thinking, it's the first automatic I've driven where I didn't feel the need to use the paddles all the time. 8 speeds also offered a very relaxed cruise at high speeds.

The only downside is low speed maneuverability isn't as good as the older torque converter gearbox, but that is to be expected. It isn't awkward by any stretch.

I'd say it's definitely worth the extra money if you can stretch, plus you'll always get a fair chunk of it back come resale time.