Mid-2000s Mini Auto Box?

Mid-2000s Mini Auto Box?

Author
Discussion

DaveyBoyWonder

Original Poster:

2,686 posts

180 months

Monday 14th December 2015
quotequote all
I'm looking at all kinds of options for the wife at the minute and she needs a cheapish auto to run around in and make the odd longer journey. There are a few auto Minis for our budget but no idea of what to look out for in these or how reliable the auto box is in them? I understand they changed the box design around 2005 - was this to correct some massive failure in the earlier ones?

Any advice appreciated!
Cheers
Dave

0llie

3,032 posts

202 months

Monday 14th December 2015
quotequote all
The 1st generation One and Cooper automatic gearbox has a very poor reputation. The first generation cars were built from 2001 until ~October 2006. They're a CVT unit and seem to be a bit hit and miss reliability wise, but sadly most do seem to fail costing an eye watering sum to fix. I've never experienced one, but I would avoid.

The 1st gen Cooper S offered a normal 6 speed torque converter auto from 2004 facelift onwards, these seem ok.

The 2nd generation One and Cooper had the same Aisin 6 speed auto as the 1st gen Cooper S which is much better than the old CVT, I haven't heard of any failures or nasties with those.