Rolls-Royce Ghost and Benley Mulsanne Top Gear tonight...

Rolls-Royce Ghost and Benley Mulsanne Top Gear tonight...

Author
Discussion

Thin White Duke

Original Poster:

2,359 posts

167 months

Sunday 6th February 2011
quotequote all
being tested in Albania and involving a dead fat man.

I hope they do a decent job of showing off these cars though.

Thin White Duke

Original Poster:

2,359 posts

167 months

Sunday 6th February 2011
quotequote all
And before anyone mentions it, yes it's meant to say Bentley in the title.

Lambo FirstBlood

983 posts

186 months

Sunday 6th February 2011
quotequote all
I bet Bentley are seriously regretting not being involved. Bottled it?

Thin White Duke

Original Poster:

2,359 posts

167 months

Monday 7th February 2011
quotequote all
It wasn't a good advert for Bentley was it. I'm not sure how these shows work behind the scenes.

Maybe TG could have simply hired a Bentley?

buyer&seller

802 posts

185 months

Monday 7th February 2011
quotequote all
I'm guessing that the trip to Albania was filmed some time ago, the first cars weren't delivered for demo's and customers until November time. So I would think that Crewe weren't happy with the car they planned to lend so pulled out at the last minute, you would think that it could have been handled better though.

Lambo FirstBlood

983 posts

186 months

Monday 7th February 2011
quotequote all
[quote=buyer&seller]I'm guessing that the trip to Albania was filmed some time ago, the first cars weren't delivered for demo's and customers until November time. So I would think that Crewe weren't happy with the car they planned to lend so pulled out at the last minute, you would think that it could have been handled better though.
[/quote]

Surely, if that was the case, Clarkson and co wouldn't' have been quite so harsh.

I think, they asked Bentley to do a test on track and Bentley agreed. When they then told them it was a group test in Albania including a Ghost, they changed their mind. I have no basis for this assumption, but this would explain why TG did what they did.

As a side, I completely agree with their final comment. If I was at the lights in a Ghost and a Phantom pulled up next to me, I would feel like I'd bought the wrong car.

I have driven the Ghost and all of the Phantom variants (apart from for the EWB, which I have been in the back of).

Whilst in its own right, it is an excellent car, IMHO it is nowhere near as special as any of the Phantom family

JonathanKK

24 posts

223 months

Monday 7th February 2011
quotequote all
After TG caused nearly €50k damage to the last 2 Bentleys lent them, it's no surprise they wouldn't give out another one.

Thin White Duke

Original Poster:

2,359 posts

167 months

Monday 7th February 2011
quotequote all
JonathanKK said:
After TG caused nearly €50k damage to the last 2 Bentleys lent them, it's no surprise they wouldn't give out another one.
Really? When was this, and which models did they damage?

Thin White Duke

Original Poster:

2,359 posts

167 months

Monday 7th February 2011
quotequote all
Lambo FirstBlood said:
As a side, I completely agree with their final comment. If I was at the lights in a Ghost and a Phantom pulled up next to me, I would feel like I'd bought the wrong car.

I have driven the Ghost and all of the Phantom variants (apart from for the EWB, which I have been in the back of).

Whilst in its own right, it is an excellent car, IMHO it is nowhere near as special as any of the Phantom family
Isn't the Ghost supposed to be the car to "drive" rather than the Phantom which is to be "driven" in? Or would you say the Phantom/s are still very much drivers cars just the same?

Lambo FirstBlood

983 posts

186 months

Monday 7th February 2011
quotequote all
Thin White Duke said:
Lambo FirstBlood said:
As a side, I completely agree with their final comment. If I was at the lights in a Ghost and a Phantom pulled up next to me, I would feel like I'd bought the wrong car.

I have driven the Ghost and all of the Phantom variants (apart from for the EWB, which I have been in the back of).

Whilst in its own right, it is an excellent car, IMHO it is nowhere near as special as any of the Phantom family
Isn't the Ghost supposed to be the car to "drive" rather than the Phantom which is to be "driven" in? Or would you say the Phantom/s are still very much drivers cars just the same?
The Ghost is certainly a more engaging drive but for my money a Phantom Coupe/Drop head with the sports package offers a better ride position, more sense of occasion and a more authentic Rolls Royce experience.


HenryRoyce

453 posts

166 months

Wednesday 9th February 2011
quotequote all
Lambo FirstBlood said:
The Ghost is certainly a more engaging drive but for my money a Phantom Coupe/Drop head with the sports package offers a better ride position, more sense of occasion and a more authentic Rolls Royce experience.
Having driven the Ghost and Phantom I have to agree with that. The Ghost is a stunningly good car, but the Phantom raises the bar to another level and feels more like a Royce should. The conventional steel monocoque of the Ghost certainly shows itself when hustled down a twisty B-road, compared to the rigid bonded aluminium structure of the Phantom on the same route.