How much is too much?

How much is too much?

Author
Discussion

Pothole

Original Poster:

34,367 posts

288 months

Saturday 22nd June 2013
quotequote all
Just laid out £700 on my GTI6 and it needs about the same over the next year to be in really good shape. I can do some things myself but my living arrangements don't really allow for the car to be up on stands for days on end while I tinker with it.

Thing is, it now owes me two and a half bags and I'll struggle to get 1.5 if I sell....

jord294

238 posts

180 months

Tuesday 25th June 2013
quotequote all
£700 isn't a lot

i only refreshed all the suspension on my rallye, and it came to over £1200.

you can do it on the cheap, but you'll only fork out more often.

i rebuild axles for 306s, and always use genuine parts. they sell for £450. i even fit them for extra fee.

what sort of work needs doing to your car?

Pet Troll

1,362 posts

184 months

Tuesday 25th June 2013
quotequote all
It does seem a pain to be shelling out to repair parts, but at least once they are repaired or replaced at least you know they are good for a while. If you were to sell the car, unless you bought a brand new car to replace it you wouldn't know what parts would need replacing on the replacement car.

As I see it, if you think you are going to keep the car for a long time then keep repairing it and enjoying it, otherwise run it into the ground or sell it for whatever you can get for it.

I'm lucky I've never had to pay out too much for repairs in my old pugs, when I have had major problems I have tied it in with planned modifications like upgrading the engine.

D4MJT

1,267 posts

164 months

Tuesday 25th June 2013
quotequote all
I think with cars at this end of the "value" market, you need to ask not "what it's worth", but "what's it worth to you"?

I have a Saxo VTS with some fairly choice mods, that I could reuse on another 10sax if I wanted. I'm probably in it for around £3k including original purchase price of the car, and on a good day it's probably worth £700.

I'd be hard pushed to find something as fun and cheap to modify for the money though, it's worth £3k all day long to me!

Pothole

Original Poster:

34,367 posts

288 months

Tuesday 25th June 2013
quotequote all
Thanks, chaps, that's kind of the conclusion I was coming to...kind of nice to know I'm not alone in my madness!

AlexRS2782

8,152 posts

219 months

Tuesday 25th June 2013
quotequote all
D4MJT said:
I think with cars at this end of the "value" market, you need to ask not "what it's worth", but "what's it worth to you"?

I have a Saxo VTS with some fairly choice mods, that I could reuse on another 10sax if I wanted. I'm probably in it for around £3k including original purchase price of the car, and on a good day it's probably worth £700.

I'd be hard pushed to find something as fun and cheap to modify for the money though, it's worth £3k all day long to me!
I'm in a similar situation with my VTS at the moment as well - looks like the bottom end went after I did a track day earlier in the year, so I parked it up & put it aside to make a decision to keep or strip, etc.

Every time I go to strip the good bits off to sell them & then move the car on as a rolling shell / project for someone else, I remind myself of what I've already spent on the car (mainly on the rear beam rebuild about 18 months ago). It's all very well and good selling it but i'll still have to replace it with another car, as a backup to my 205, and seeing as the replacement car would also have to get bought on a budget, chances are that would also need £££ spending on it.

At which point I go back to my original thoughts of thinking I may as well just source a known working engine from another VTS / 106 GTI being broken & swap it over to get mine back on the road. Just a shame that every time I decide it's time to do it, I end up spending the £££ on my 205 instead hehe

dai1983

2,987 posts

155 months

Saturday 29th June 2013
quotequote all
Just think of the depreciation on a new car and you will feel better! I do most of my own mechanical repairs but rust and tatty paintwork depresses me and costs a bigger fortune again!

Pothole

Original Poster:

34,367 posts

288 months

Saturday 29th June 2013
quotequote all
Went to get tyres the other day and one of my new drop links has popped off the top ball joint connection! grr!

jord294

238 posts

180 months

Wednesday 3rd July 2013
quotequote all
was this a genuine part drop link?

best pattern parts i use are lemforder

D4MJT

1,267 posts

164 months

Wednesday 3rd July 2013
quotequote all
agreed there, the Lemforder parts are better than the OEM Citroen Saxo VTS drop links, the threaded bolt you put through the suspension strut and secure with a nut has an internal hex so you can hold it still and use a ring spanner to tighten it, where as the OEM parts you have to attempt to clamp, or get a windy gun on.

Still seem fine after 7k of hard abuse as well.

Pothole

Original Poster:

34,367 posts

288 months

Thursday 4th July 2013
quotequote all
Taking it back in today tomorrow, no idea what parts were used, but the work was done by a reasonably well known local (Leicester) indy French car specialist who posts on here...the mech I spoke to when I saw what had happened said "they're a nightmare" so it's not unusual by the sound of things.

Edited by Pothole on Thursday 4th July 09:11

Pet Troll

1,362 posts

184 months

Friday 5th July 2013
quotequote all
Pothole said:
Taking it back in today tomorrow, no idea what parts were used, but the work was done by a reasonably well known local (Leicester) indy French car specialist who posts on here...the mech I spoke to when I saw what had happened said "they're a nightmare" so it's not unusual by the sound of things.

Edited by Pothole on Thursday 4th July 09:11
Oh dear, I hope it's not the one in Leicester that is well known in Pug circles for being dodgy as hell?