206 GTI or 206 GTI 180

206 GTI or 206 GTI 180

Author
Discussion

Bezza1969

Original Poster:

777 posts

154 months

Friday 7th June 2013
quotequote all
..well Mrs Bezza's 205 GTI may be sold soon after 10 years, simply because it needs a bit of TLC and we aren't do it yourself type car people, so we are wondering if it might not be time for a more modern motor with less of the compromises you get with an old 205 (I.e, no PAS, no air-con, bloody loud at speed since the exhaust was replaced...!)

Keeping the sporting hatchback theme, she likes the Fiesta ST, but these are quite expensive. On the other hand I've noticed how cheap 206 GTIs are. Never rated by the motoring press I know, but surely they ain't that bad and but I've seen a 50K mile 206 GTI 180 locally for just 2 grand, so any feedback please on what the 206 GTi and 180 are like to own. Are they any good?

Simes205

4,615 posts

234 months

Saturday 8th June 2013
quotequote all
Both are dull after the 205, the gti is not up to it. The 180 is a better car.

What's up with the 205?

framerateuk

2,771 posts

190 months

Sunday 9th June 2013
quotequote all
Just to mention, the Fiesta ST, while a great little car, has unfortunately become the victim of thieves the past few years as people steal the bumpers, spoilers and side skirts to put them onto other Fiestas. Had it happen to mine and it was a nightmare.

Unless it's going to be garaged or you live out of the way, I'd avoid for that reason!

A205GTI

750 posts

172 months

Sunday 9th June 2013
quotequote all

If you get one, you are already used to the rattles from the dash.

I know of a few people who had them, drove one of them insane!!

To be fair not bad cars just rattle and squeak. (Brother has one)

Me I am restoring the 205 at the moment.

unless something major wrong with the 205 I would keep it myself.

Simes205

4,615 posts

234 months

Sunday 9th June 2013
quotequote all
just noticed your location.
You live near one of the best authorities on the 205GTI in the country.
Get it fixed up.

www.pugracing.com

kayzee

2,939 posts

187 months

Monday 10th June 2013
quotequote all
I had a 206 GTi... and tbh I thought it was a bargain when I paid just over £2,500 for it years ago. However you need to be careful with them as quite a high number have a problem where the engine will randomly cut out. Totally ignored by Peugeot (it came on Watchdog but they did nothing)

Mine had this which eventually led me to sell it as it was quite dangerous, would cut out down the motorway or going round roundabouts mainly. There's been lots of research into this problem but there is no fix.

Bezza1969

Original Poster:

777 posts

154 months

Monday 10th June 2013
quotequote all
Simes205 said:
just noticed your location.
You live near one of the best authorities on the 205GTI in the country.
Get it fixed up.

www.pugracing.com
Thanks! and thanks for the ringing 205 endorsements everybody!!

Simes205

4,615 posts

234 months

Monday 10th June 2013
quotequote all
Bezza1969 said:
Simes205 said:
just noticed your location.
You live near one of the best authorities on the 205GTI in the country.
Get it fixed up.

www.pugracing.com
Thanks! and thanks for the ringing 205 endorsements everybody!!
Good good!

Tell him I sent you.

GTiFrank

625 posts

190 months

Sunday 16th June 2013
quotequote all
I've owned my GTi 138 for 3 years now and I'm a fan. Can be picked up for very little. Mine seems to be built very well, no sqweaks or rattles.

Watch out for rattling exhaust manifolds but other than that drivetrain is under stressed and reliable. Lots for toys as standard and pulls around 4k a an 85mph cruise so not too loud.

Go for a 180 if you want something quick out the box or a 138 if you want to fettle.

philmots

4,643 posts

266 months

Monday 17th June 2013
quotequote all
The wife has had a 138 GTI for nearly 4 years now, only issue being an abs sensor and the air con packed in last summer..

Done routine maintenance, timing belt/water pump and clutch kit.. it just keeps going. Now on 64k. Really happy with it.

It's not a great hot hatch but as a car it's ok.. Compared to the 180, I'd like to have the seats but that's it. I much prefer the look for the 138 - specially the wheels and costs are lower. The 180 has a very expensive 2nd cat amongst other things.

I plan to get rid of ours at some point this year and will probably replace it with a 207 GT

bertieg

603 posts

147 months

Monday 17th June 2013
quotequote all
i like the look of them, and definitely considered one to replace my saxo vts. in the end i went clio 172, and i think i made the right choice. the same money will get you a good one, and its rated everywhere as the better hot hatch, and is still a fantastic daily car

philmots

4,643 posts

266 months

Monday 17th June 2013
quotequote all
I had a 172 Cup years back and it was a lot better car really..

At the time of buying our 138 a 172 wasn't an option as having ESP was a priority.. The later 172 with ESP and any 182 weren't in budget at the time.

206 is slightly bigger which was a bonus, has a lot nicer dash, and IMO looks better on the outside. That's about it though'!

S10GTA

12,937 posts

173 months

Wednesday 19th June 2013
quotequote all
Girlfriend had a 138, I quite liked it. I would recommend the 180 as its the same engine I have in my C4 VTS


dai1983

2,987 posts

155 months

Thursday 20th June 2013
quotequote all
Yeah what's up with the 205? How's it doing rust wise as I'm looking for a project.

Lewisp12

77 posts

139 months

Thursday 20th June 2013
quotequote all
Keep the 205!!!