need for engine rebuild how do you know ?

need for engine rebuild how do you know ?

Author
Discussion

Funky Jo

Original Poster:

164 posts

196 months

Friday 19th June 2009
quotequote all
There are many contributions on here, where and what and why are the alternatives to have a top-end and/or bottom end engine rebuild.
What are the certain indicators / symptoms for the need of a rebuild, while the engine is still doing its job? How would you - as a normal Speed Six driver - notice, before the engine goes bang and what exactly does this mean / what exactly goes bang there and how do you see, hear, smell or feel it?

Far Eastender

1,361 posts

224 months

Saturday 20th June 2009
quotequote all
My S6 is up to almost 40,000 miles now without any problems. I had decided after a rolling road test that I wanted to up the HP, so I decided on a rebuild and upgrade to Red Rose spec.

In spite of no problems with the car in the three years I've owned it, the engine was eating the finger followers. The damage was so bad that the bottom end has got to be replaced.

I wouldn't have known about, it unless the engine had been taken apart or it went BOOM!

Daston

6,112 posts

209 months

Saturday 20th June 2009
quotequote all
Mine has started to puff blue smoke on a cold start and the end cans have become quite sooty after the last 200 or so miles (need to give it a wash). Signs are warn valve guides so engine out and top end rebuild.

Tamster.

534 posts

216 months

Saturday 20th June 2009
quotequote all
First sign's are one or both of the tailpipe's puffin blue or black (especially when cold) excessive oil consumption, ie more than 1 litre per 1k road miles, the engine can still sound and run fine at this point, if in doubt have the cam cover off and check how much adjustment is left on the shim's, not all of them go out in a blaze of glory! tongue out

Robertjp

2,281 posts

231 months

Monday 22nd June 2009
quotequote all
Far Eastender said:
My S6 is up to almost 40,000 miles now without any problems. I had decided after a rolling road test that I wanted to up the HP, so I decided on a rebuild and upgrade to Red Rose spec.

In spite of no problems with the car in the three years I've owned it, the engine was eating the finger followers. The damage was so bad that the bottom end has got to be replaced.

I wouldn't have known about, it unless the engine had been taken apart or it went BOOM!
How much power are you hoping to gain? Mines in for rebuild at moment, just checking out options!

for info for the OP - 3 weeks into ownership and i have done 800 miles and used 3.5 litres of oil - i kinda guessed from that i had some serious problems! It had a top end rebuild the year previous....i guess it just wasnt done properly!

KillerJim

969 posts

209 months

Tuesday 23rd June 2009
quotequote all
Robertjp said:
for info for the OP - 3 weeks into ownership and i have done 800 miles and used 3.5 litres of oil - i kinda guessed from that i had some serious problems! It had a top end rebuild the year previous....i guess it just wasnt done properly!
redfaceredface

3.5 litres in 800 miles.. for contrast I haven`t used any oil in about 3000 miles! I would get someone to check this out asap.

J

Funky Jo

Original Poster:

164 posts

196 months

Tuesday 23rd June 2009
quotequote all
OK, so blue, or black smoke seem to be the early visual (and probably smellish) indicators then.
Anything else, one could hear or feel, like a rattling or knocking or similar?

PascalBuyens

2,868 posts

288 months

Tuesday 23rd June 2009
quotequote all
Few weeks before mine went down the gutter, it started to make a slight "whistling" sound when revving it...

when it finally went, it did it in TVR style... Loud, fast and brute wink (even though I was at a constant speed of 75mph)

dvs_dave

8,978 posts

231 months

Tuesday 23rd June 2009
quotequote all
Typical failure modes are:

Loud tapping - top end blown and catastrophic failure imminent through debris jamming the oil pump(s).

Noticable over normal whistling/whirring - half time bearing on the way out and catastrophic failure imminent due to bearing collapse leading to timing chain failure.

High oil consumption - most likely worn valve guides (sometimes worn piston rings but less likely). Will get worse and worse until it eventually drops a valve.

BANG - Usually a spun/siezed big end bearing.




Edited by dvs_dave on Tuesday 23 June 16:29

Fume troll

4,389 posts

218 months

Tuesday 23rd June 2009
quotequote all
Mine was caught early. Down a bit on compression, plus high HCs and some exhaust smoke on one bank of cylinders. It wasn't particularly rough or noisy, but it is considerably smoother now.

Cheers,

FT.

da_murphster

1,052 posts

253 months

Monday 29th June 2009
quotequote all
Are you best to just keep driving it until you are sure something is wrong or is it worth (and financially viable) to do any type of confirmatory check.

Is it considerably cheaper/better if you 'catch it early'??