2-11 to exige s
Author
Discussion

hodgre

Original Poster:

81 posts

221 months

Friday 19th February 2010
quotequote all
Thinking of swapping 2-11 for an exige
with performance pack. Anyone got any idea of whether there will be a big performance difference between the two on track.

TIPPER

2,955 posts

242 months

Friday 19th February 2010
quotequote all
Given the 2-11 is knocking on 200kg lighter and pacdks about 40bhp more then I'd expect so.
The Exige will also feel heavy and far less agile (certainly does compared to my S1).
A supercharged Honda powered S1 might be gthe better choice.

edp190

336 posts

232 months

Friday 19th February 2010
quotequote all
My head nearly came off at Dijon in a 2-11.
An exige is positively pedestrian in comparison. (Even my old s1 exige with a s/c honda)
HTH cheers Ed

mrdemon

21,146 posts

288 months

Friday 19th February 2010
quotequote all
how does a 2-11 have 40BHp more than a PP Exige ?

and for 2k you can have CUP spec 260BHp on your Exige if you did not know that.

Sumshi

277 posts

195 months

Friday 19th February 2010
quotequote all
Curiousity at the moment - what is the spec and how much do you want for the 2-11
Please do not hold your breath !!!

TIPPER

2,955 posts

242 months

Friday 19th February 2010
quotequote all
mrdemon said:
how does a 2-11 have 40BHp more than a PP Exige ?

and for 2k you can have CUP spec 260BHp on your Exige if you did not know that.
Exige S circa 220 vs circa 260 for 2-11.
PP wasn't mentioned.

shangani

3,069 posts

260 months

Friday 19th February 2010
quotequote all
hodgre said:
Thinking of swapping 2-11 for an exige
with performance pack.
The OP did actually mention performance pack, but Tim, you are right, an Exige would be noticeably slower than the 211 on track pace, but I wouldn't personally want to drive long distances to and from tracks in a 211.

Stephanie Plum

2,797 posts

234 months

Friday 19th February 2010
quotequote all
shangani said:
hodgre said:
Thinking of swapping 2-11 for an exige
with performance pack.
The OP did actually mention performance pack, but Tim, you are right, an Exige would be noticeably slower than the 211 on track pace, but I wouldn't personally want to drive long distances to and from tracks in a 211.
Shangers is right there - it's knackering. I driven through France, Spain and to Scotland and back in mine, and it's tiring - more so if the weather conditions are poor.

An Exige will be slower though for sure - it weighs more, regardless of whether it has a PP or not.

TIPPER

2,955 posts

242 months

Friday 19th February 2010
quotequote all
shangani said:
hodgre said:
Thinking of swapping 2-11 for an exige
with performance pack.
The OP did actually mention performance pack, but Tim, you are right, an Exige would be noticeably slower than the 211 on track pace, but I wouldn't personally want to drive long distances to and from tracks in a 211.
My eyes are failing merolleyes

I haven't driven a 2-11 but have an Exige S (with PP!!). The Exige (on track) felt very lardy immedietly after my S1.
The 2-11 is a wonderful looking machine and I'm glad Lotus made it (and people like Jo bought 'em) but if you want to drive your track car to the track then I still reckon the S1 takes some beating.
Of course it'll need some choice mods but with a supercharged Honda then it should show a 2-11 a clean pair of heels.
Of course I don't suppose that really helps the OP who's probably trying to make a purchase decision.

Gareth135R

565 posts

246 months

Saturday 20th February 2010
quotequote all
You're certainly getting more for your buck by going Exige S in terms of usability.
I had a 340R and that was bad enough even with it's full windscreen.

You'll need a PP at least. 220s are not that quick anyway.
Other options, buy a N/A and bolt on a katana kit,or maybe find a Exige 260.
IMO though, if you want a fast track car with option of aero screen or full screen with roof...it's got to be a R400/R500

scoobyc

577 posts

254 months

Saturday 20th February 2010
quotequote all
just a thought but a 220 S with this pack fitted would be getting you closer for not a lot of bucks?
http://www.oakmeremotorgroup.co.uk/lotus/offers/vi...

cyberface

12,214 posts

280 months

Saturday 20th February 2010
quotequote all
The Exige S is compromised on track performance, sure. But it's pretty much a perfect *road* car IMO. I wouldn't want to do 400 miles in one day in a 2-11, and if I'm being honest, in midwinter, I don't fancy the same trip in an S1 Elise either.

The Exige S (with PP or without, doesn't matter on the road much - just put a freer-flowing exhaust on the 220 and it feels quicker at the top end anyway) is a superb touring car that can also mix it up with more dedicated track machinery. It's a finely judged compromise. It's truly a car for all seasons AFAIAC, I love mine. It does it all.

If you're looking to buy a third car for trackdays and the odd Sunday summer blast, then you're wasting an Exige S, which is good enough to be used every day all year round (with appropriate tyres in winter, of course).

The 2-11 is the car for the other requirement. Or a Caterfield. Or, if you want to annoy everyone else on the trackday, get a Radical or similar and make everyone have to slow down on every straight to let you past, so nobody can get a clear lap rage

hehe

And remember it's all relative. Those people saying that the Exige S is 'lardy' and 'slow' on track... well it may be compared to a lightweight S1 with a Honda engine, but the bog-standard Exige S is still a bloody quick road car on track, it's cheap to run on trackdays and it'll be a LOT faster than most other cars out there. You *can* go quicker, but don't go thinking the Exige is a slow car that will get monstered by everything else on any trackday you attend...

TIPPER

2,955 posts

242 months

Saturday 20th February 2010
quotequote all
[quote=cyberface]....... if I'm being honest, in midwinter, I don't fancy the same trip in an S1 Elise either.

Big girl's blousetongue out

hehe

''And remember it's all relative. Those people saying that the Exige S is 'lardy' and 'slow' on track... well it may be compared to a lightweight S1 with a Honda engine, but the bog-standard Exige S is still a bloody quick road car on track, it's cheap to run on trackdays and it'll be a LOT faster than most other cars out there. You *can* go quicker, but don't go thinking the Exige is a slow car that will get monstered by everything else on any trackday you attend...[/quote''


Can't argue with that but coming from a 2-11 it will feel heavy. It just doesn't have the lovely chuckability that something a bit lighter has.

Edited by TIPPER on Saturday 20th February 14:18

535dBoy

474 posts

221 months

Saturday 20th February 2010
quotequote all
scoobyc said:
just a thought but a 220 S with this pack fitted would be getting you closer for not a lot of bucks?
http://www.oakmeremotorgroup.co.uk/lotus/offers/vi...
I'm planning on one of these

Been speaking with Paul up there

scoobyc

577 posts

254 months

Saturday 20th February 2010
quotequote all
would appreciate your feedback on this if you go for it, cheers.

hodgre

Original Poster:

81 posts

221 months

Sunday 21st February 2010
quotequote all
Given me food for thought.
Was also toying with the idea of a R400. However, not entirely sure whether this will meet noise regs at Bedford which is my nearest track after Oulton (until hopefully Donnington reopens). I know that 300bhp exiges are faster (at least on the straights) than a 2-11. Personally I think it is the brakes on the 2-11 that I would miss most and would be willing to sacrifice some speed for a car that I could drive to more distant circuits (cannot store trailer on my property.

To Sumshi-no real idea as to what I would want for it (launch edition registered in nov 2007 with stage 1 exhaust 9000 miles). However, with Spring approaching I'm hoping its value will increase.

535dBoy

474 posts

221 months

Monday 22nd February 2010
quotequote all
I've said yes

Just need to organise to get it there now!

aceofspades

111 posts

210 months

Monday 1st March 2010
quotequote all
scoobyc said:
just a thought but a 220 S with this pack fitted would be getting you closer for not a lot of bucks?
http://www.oakmeremotorgroup.co.uk/lotus/offers/vi...
anyone actually done this, does it land you with something identical to an S 240 ? i filled out the enquiry form last week but haven't heard back yet. going to ring them this week.

535dBoy

474 posts

221 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
aceofspades said:
scoobyc said:
just a thought but a 220 S with this pack fitted would be getting you closer for not a lot of bucks?
http://www.oakmeremotorgroup.co.uk/lotus/offers/vi...
anyone actually done this, does it land you with something identical to an S 240 ? i filled out the enquiry form last week but haven't heard back yet. going to ring them this week.
Mine is booked in

Paul is a top bloke but very busy - he is the service manager there I believe.

Just pick up phone if I was you

aceofspades

111 posts

210 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
i did, very interesting chat. just waiting on a written description to send my insurance company.

are you going for the 260 version ?