MOT confusion

Author
Discussion

dragstar

Original Poster:

3,924 posts

257 months

Sunday 18th January 2004
quotequote all
Ok guys, confession time

I bought a CAT-replacement pipe from Geary and went to get it fitted at Brucesesesees.

anyway, despite having CRP as "new" in my profile bruce discovered i already had a CRP installed (no laughing cuzza )

anyway, i gave the CRP back and rang the previous owner. he explained to me that he had not fitted it and was totally unaware of its existence (as i was, hence buying one).

thing is, he owned the car in march 2003, when it passed an MOT, including the emissions test.

WTF??

will it pass without a CATpipe?

Arno

349 posts

285 months

Sunday 18th January 2004
quotequote all
dragstar said:
will it pass without a CATpipe?


On an actual emissions test: not a hope in hell.

Sorry..

Bye, Arno.

dragstar

Original Poster:

3,924 posts

257 months

Sunday 18th January 2004
quotequote all
Cheers Arno,

the plot thickens!

either he lied about having knowledge of the CRP or had a dodgy testor.

my dodgy MOT testor has gone AWOL

pies

13,116 posts

263 months

Sunday 18th January 2004
quotequote all
If your ignorant of the fact that it will only pass the emmissions test with one, why assume you have one

dragstar

Original Poster:

3,924 posts

257 months

Sunday 18th January 2004
quotequote all


sooooo, your saying if i go in with my mouth shut it may pass?

pies

13,116 posts

263 months

Sunday 18th January 2004
quotequote all
What im saying is the previous owner might not have realised he needed one to pass an mot

dragstar

Original Poster:

3,924 posts

257 months

Sunday 18th January 2004
quotequote all
ahh ok.

how did it pass then?

i hope your not saying something which im not getting

im feeling quite thick today

pies

13,116 posts

263 months

Sunday 18th January 2004
quotequote all
It passec cos it had one fitted (without the owner knowing)

You don't need to know how a car works (much) to drive it

dragstar

Original Poster:

3,924 posts

257 months

Sunday 18th January 2004
quotequote all
i should be more clear

i had two CRPs one on the car (i didnt know about) and one i bought. the one i gave back was the one i bought so at current my car is running a CRP and i dont have the CAT to just swap over

on its last MOT it had a CRP but the owner didnt know.

how the f**k did it pass?

>> Edited by dragstar on Sunday 18th January 18:04

dragstar

Original Poster:

3,924 posts

257 months

Sunday 18th January 2004
quotequote all
Leaving that aside, any advice as to what to do for the MOT?

B19GRR

1,980 posts

263 months

Sunday 18th January 2004
quotequote all
I'd suggest dropping a note on NORLOG along the lines of "Need MOT but not got a CAT, any suggestions?"

Alternatively just buy my car, I currently have OEM CAT, Sports CAT fitted and spare CRP, but I just like ot show off

Cheers,
Rob

malbon

280 posts

268 months

Sunday 18th January 2004
quotequote all
You probably are never going to find out.

Either.

1. The previous owner is lying and has lost/sold the CAT. (You can get a good price for them)

2. The MOT centre might have thought "Why is this thing not passing? - we haven't worked on one of these cars before and dont fancy prodding around this late in the day - it is friday afternoon after all - ah fcuck it - sign the slip"

3. The calibration of the MOT's equipment was out.

4. The little beauty just got lucky.

Either way. Don't worry about it. Ask one of the nice members on here who has a CRP fitted to borrow their cat for the day.

Sorted geezer.

dragstar

Original Poster:

3,924 posts

257 months

Sunday 18th January 2004
quotequote all
Cheers guys,

i remember the day clearly.

Me: "right dad, im off to go see it with jason"

dad: "just make sure its got a flippin CAT"

me: "will do"

.......

me: "does it have a cat?"

owner: "oh yes...do you want to check?"

me: (whilst checking over the whole history of the car showing nothing) "nah i trust you"
.....................................

me: (jan 2004)

dad: (if he finds out)

and then

anyway, i have asked for a place in manchester on Norlog, under a new name (see if you can spot me! ) and if nothing happens then ill just chance it!

cheers fellas

p.s. it is not unheard of for cars to pass, de-catted. a bloke i kind of knew had a near 500bhp de-catted skyline pass without a problem!

fergusd

1,247 posts

277 months

Sunday 18th January 2004
quotequote all
Bloke I know of had an S1 111S pass it's MOT in the last month without an CAT fitted . . .

I have also heard that if you declare "this car has no cat" then some MOT testers will test it based on a non catted car . . . which the Elise will pass easily . . .

It's not as black and white as "it can't pass without a CAT" regardless of the legality . . .

go figure . . .

Fd

dragstar

Original Poster:

3,924 posts

257 months

Monday 19th January 2004
quotequote all
cheers Ferg!

i know it happens, just got to find the right centre

cuzza

2,042 posts

260 months

Monday 19th January 2004
quotequote all
dragstar said:
no laughing cuzza



























I tried

dragstar

Original Poster:

3,924 posts

257 months

Monday 19th January 2004
quotequote all
tit

stone

1,538 posts

254 months

Monday 19th January 2004
quotequote all
FWIW . It is possible for some vehicles that are in a good state of tune and also are upto temperature when tested. (i.e A good sound thrashing immediately prior to test) to pass emmissions tests without a cat.

Cheers

Stone

dragstar

Original Poster:

3,924 posts

257 months

Monday 19th January 2004
quotequote all
cheers Stone

westfield owner...good-lad

just got my westfield brochere through the post

cuzza

2,042 posts

260 months

Monday 19th January 2004
quotequote all
Only playing!

Can someone 'lend' you a CAT? Maybe one of the NORLOG guys has a CRP but still has the CAT in their garage?

It shouldn't be a difficult job to change it over for a day, undertray off, undo six bolts, remove CRP - fit CAT, replace undertray (very important - if it can't be seen, it can't be tested), have car tested. Reverse procedure above and buy your mate a beer