Buy an Exige S or an N/A and retro fit SC or TC? Advice

Buy an Exige S or an N/A and retro fit SC or TC? Advice

Author
Discussion

m1nky

Original Poster:

142 posts

212 months

Tuesday 1st May 2012
quotequote all
Having owned an 06 Exige a few years back I can honestly say its the best car I've ever owned. I'm looking at buying another Exige of a similar age but not sure if the factory S is worth the extra money or to buy the NA and consider an after market supercharger or turbo
I think I would save £4000 minimum in buying an NA and there seems to be a greater choice.
Any advice would be appreciated.

4340BB

857 posts

213 months

Wednesday 2nd May 2012
quotequote all
Hi m1inky.
I am on my 3rd Exige now after owning a n/a s2 then a s/c s2 I have now gone back to a n/a as I find it a better driving experience to suit my needs.
However, if my engine does let go for any reason I would be looking at either a Honda or Audi conversion as I think that is where the sensible money would go. £ for bhp if you catch my drift.

So, a £4000 saving would go towards the engine conversion if it was my decision.
But it's not. It's yours, and what do I know!!!

bernie_eccle

296 posts

251 months

Wednesday 2nd May 2012
quotequote all
If you spend £4k on an after market SC you will get next to none of this value back on resale. If you buy an S you will get more of your money back. Worth thinking about.

21TonyK

11,784 posts

214 months

Thursday 3rd May 2012
quotequote all
bernie_eccle said:
If you spend £4k on an after market SC you will get next to none of this value back on resale. If you buy an S you will get more of your money back. Worth thinking about.
Agreed, I'd go with an S and up it to 240.

Captain Muppet

8,540 posts

270 months

Thursday 3rd May 2012
quotequote all
Test drive an example of both an NA and an S and see which one you prefer.

PaulB81

883 posts

165 months

Thursday 3rd May 2012
quotequote all
m1nky said:
Having owned an 06 Exige a few years back I can honestly say its the best car I've ever owned. I'm looking at buying another Exige of a similar age but not sure if the factory S is worth the extra money or to buy the NA and consider an after market supercharger or turbo
I think I would save £4000 minimum in buying an NA and there seems to be a greater choice.
Any advice would be appreciated.
This is interesting. I have been thinking about supercharging my 111R. What was it about the SC that you didnt like? wouldnt want to spend all that money then regret it.

m1nky

Original Poster:

142 posts

212 months

Friday 4th May 2012
quotequote all
PaulB81 said:
This is interesting. I have been thinking about supercharging my 111R. What was it about the SC that you didnt like? wouldnt want to spend all that money then regret it.
The Exige S is the best car I have ever owned, and I've been fortunate enough to have a few. I have driven an NA and for me there is no comparison, so much more torque from the SC. I just wondered how that compared to an aftermarket conversion.
However thanks partly to the advice above, yesterday I put a deposit on a beautiful low mileage S with great spec in gleaming dog cock red :-) I feel like a kid at Christmas already!

Speckle

3,462 posts

221 months

Friday 4th May 2012
quotequote all
I had an aftermarket supercharger conversion on my n/a Exige (Katana) and it really is the best thing I ever did. The car is transformed and I firmly believe all Exiges should have left the factory with a supercharger! I have driven a standard S (220) and the aftermarket kit feels quite a bit quicker tbh.

Financially, a factory S is the better option in terms of resale value. For me, this was never a consideration, I simply wanted to improve a car I was already in love with smile

Either way, hope you enjoy yours drivingthumbup