Billy Connolly

Author
Discussion

mcecm

Original Poster:

674 posts

274 months

Sunday 12th December 2004
quotequote all
Has anyone been watching his series on Saturday nights? I think he's the best comedian in this country by a long way. Stuff the people that complained about the Ken Bigley affair. If you're easily offended, stay away! I'll now be measuring everything in denominations of the standard scone.

wedg1e

26,891 posts

272 months

Sunday 12th December 2004
quotequote all
I heard that much of his stuff is unscripted, he just ad-libs his way through it (it shows in places too). If you look really hard, he's not THAT funny... but I still laugh at him anyway

chassis 33

6,194 posts

289 months

Sunday 12th December 2004
quotequote all
mcecm said:
Has anyone been watching his series on Saturday nights? I think he's the best comedian in this country by a long way. Stuff the people that complained about the Ken Bigley affair. If you're easily offended, stay away! I'll now be measuring everything in denominations of the standard scone.


Is that the plain or sultana scone though???
I love his material, not that i like the foul language, but if you can't survive in this day and age without being offended by fk you aint going to get far.

The piece about the protests in the various languages last week had me in stitches for ages.

Regards
Iain

The DJ 27

2,666 posts

260 months

Sunday 12th December 2004
quotequote all
chassis 33 said:

[The piece about the protests in the various languages last week had me in stitches for ages.

Regards
Iain



How funny was that? I was crying with laughter. Missed it this week due to being in the pub

wedg1e

26,891 posts

272 months

Sunday 12th December 2004
quotequote all
los angeles said:

wedg1e said:
I heard that much of his stuff is unscripted, he just ad-libs his way through it (it shows in places too). If you look really hard, he's not THAT funny... but I still laugh at him anyway

He's a naturally funny person, Wedg1e, but most of his material is borrowed, or observed, and well rehearsed. It's his ability to spin it out a yarn, based on repeated telling, that keeps us laughing. But you're right, he's not as funny as he once was mainly because he has long since left behind the inspirational source of his comedy ... Scottish folk and their ways.


His wife was interviewed a few years back, it was she who said he makes it up as he goes along.
True though, there is a lot of comedy that is based on the simple representation of character traits, from the Two Ronnies country bumpkins to the Royle family, Victor Meldrew etc etc.

Mrs Fish

30,018 posts

265 months

Sunday 12th December 2004
quotequote all
I don't find him funny

tvrgit

8,473 posts

259 months

Sunday 12th December 2004
quotequote all
He always explains that he has a rough idea of what he is going to talk about, but he winds is way through it in a random order and adds bits in and takes bits out as he feels like it.

He started off as a folk singer in a group known as the Humblebums (with Gerry Rafferty who wrote "Baker Street" and "Stuck in the Middle with You") and started telling wee ad-lib stories between songs - eventually the stories started taking over the act and they went their separate ways.

He's funny because he points out how ridiculous most of life really is...

iansull

1,940 posts

253 months

Sunday 12th December 2004
quotequote all
Mrs Fish said:
I don't find him funny


me neither

Esprit

6,370 posts

290 months

Sunday 12th December 2004
quotequote all
I think he's wonderful... although his material might not be the funniest at times, I always find his delivery to be spot-on

Apache

39,731 posts

291 months

Sunday 12th December 2004
quotequote all
los angeles said:

wedg1e said:
I heard that much of his stuff is unscripted, he just ad-libs his way through it (it shows in places too). If you look really hard, he's not THAT funny... but I still laugh at him anyway

He's a naturally funny person, Wedg1e, but most of his material is borrowed, or observed, and well rehearsed. It's his ability to spin it out a yarn, based on repeated telling, that keeps us laughing. But you're right, he's not as funny as he once was mainly because he has long since left behind the inspirational source of his comedy ... Scottish folk and their ways.



I've read a fair bit about him, he does indeed adlib, senses how things are going and takes it from there. LA made a good point about his source of material being a bit more cosmopolitan but his Oz sketches were sublime

motco

16,228 posts

253 months

Sunday 12th December 2004
quotequote all
I agree that he's not as funny as he once was - I used to rate him and Mike Harding as the joint funniest on tv. He is wearingly frantic, perhaps it's the mixture of the sublime lanscape with his manic stage show. His wife is, of course, the delectable Pamela Stephenson, a beauty with a brain the size of a planet. Still delectable if a bit "mature" now.

lightningghost

4,943 posts

256 months

Sunday 12th December 2004
quotequote all
Nope. I dobn't like him. I prefer Lee Evans from a few years ago.

D_Mike

5,301 posts

247 months

Sunday 12th December 2004
quotequote all
The greatest comics don't need to swear. Check out Wodehouse! That is sublime comedy. I don't like billy connelly very much...

srebbe64

13,021 posts

244 months

Sunday 12th December 2004
quotequote all
Billy Connolly is a naturally funny bloke, which people seem to either love or hate. I think he's got a very quick brain, which performs best when he has a plan/material in mind but wanders off the subject, like a rambler leaving the path when the mood grabs him.

He is similar in some way to Tommy Cooper. Obviously the style and content are totally different, but with both of them the audience just seems to laugh when they walk on stage.

With regard to his swearing, for some reason it doesn't come across as terribly offensive - don't know how he does it though.

mybrainhurts

90,809 posts

262 months

Sunday 12th December 2004
quotequote all
Funniest man on the planet.......

alexkp

16,484 posts

251 months

Sunday 12th December 2004
quotequote all
mybrainhurts said:
Funniest man on the planet.......



Can't agree.

Robin Williams geuinely doesn't script, and is a true genius of stand-up. He is the one that most comedians rate as the best of all.

No two shows he does are ever the same.

mybrainhurts

90,809 posts

262 months

Sunday 12th December 2004
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]


BC claims that, too. Won a bet with someone who doubted him...two consecutive nights.

zooooom

1,310 posts

267 months

Sunday 12th December 2004
quotequote all
Personally I can't watch Robin Williams & Billy Connolly back to back as it make my stomach and cheeks ache to much.

Wacky Racer

38,987 posts

254 months

Sunday 12th December 2004
quotequote all
chassis 33 said:

Is that the plain or sultana scone though???
I love his material, not that i like the foul language, but if you can't survive in this day and age without being offended by fk you aint going to get far.




Yet another example of how far this once great country of ours has sunk into the gutter....

Just walk down any high street passing a group of young kids, male or female, every other sentence has the "F" word in it..........

Billy is a naturally funny man, and a clever one at that, he does not need the "industrial" language to get his laughs, unlike a lot of other comedians.....

stackmonkey

5,077 posts

256 months

Monday 13th December 2004
quotequote all
True, but that combines with the high level of observation is a large part of what helps to make him so funny.

I'll be getting the DVD.