Ultimate engine, the BD series???

Author
Discussion

bmcoopers

Original Poster:

17 posts

182 months

Friday 11th September 2009
quotequote all
what is your opinion of the ultimate engine?i love the bdg engines as they sound absolutely fantastic, they stand out a mile. the reason i out this in the classic car section is to be honest the old engines are more fun, i'd love to have a bdt out of the rs200 in my mk2 escort, infact scrap that id be quite happy with an rs200 (ive seen em going for over 100k,whats that about!!!!)
anyway put your opinion down...

aeropilot

36,241 posts

233 months

Friday 11th September 2009
quotequote all
bmcoopers said:
what is your opinion of the ultimate engine?
Chrysler Hemi for me wink

Edited by aeropilot on Friday 11th September 15:05

a8hex

5,830 posts

229 months

Friday 11th September 2009
quotequote all
bmcoopers said:
what is your opinion of the ultimate engine?
XK

Does everything from winning Le Mans to powering an almost tank

williamp

19,493 posts

279 months

Friday 11th September 2009
quotequote all
Cosworth DFV? the most successful f1 racing engine, ever
Porsche flat 6 for longevity and power
Colombo V12 for the Ferrari?

shoestring7

6,139 posts

252 months

Monday 14th September 2009
quotequote all
BMW S14 at is up there, esp at 8000rpm: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fHBJwVXKViE

The BD series sounds flat IMO

SS7

Edited by shoestring7 on Monday 14th September 16:19

onomatopoeia

3,481 posts

223 months

Monday 14th September 2009
quotequote all
Coventry Climax FWMA

(I would say that, of course)

lowdrag

13,025 posts

219 months

Monday 14th September 2009
quotequote all
Bugatti for beauty and engineering although the 6C and 8C Alfas run them close. Can't find the picture for the moment but the Royale engine is pure awesome.

TaimarSE

87 posts

216 months

Tuesday 15th September 2009
quotequote all
Boss 302 cloud9

Mark A S

1,893 posts

194 months

Wednesday 16th September 2009
quotequote all
I agree, you can’t beat a Mk 1 or 2 BDA/G/X Escort at 9000rpm in a forest, awesome noise, even from inside the car smile Have to admit, a TR8 comes close though!
One of the best engine sounds IMO is the BRM V16, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fZMPDCNyQxE that puts the hairs on the back of your neck up!

AJAX50

418 posts

246 months

Wednesday 16th September 2009
quotequote all
The BDA made the Escort into an international winner, the BRM engine bye the way was an H 16, the youtube clip does sound like two V8's!
Mark A S said:
I agree, you can’t beat a Mk 1 or 2 BDA/G/X Escort at 9000rpm in a forest, awesome noise, even from inside the car smile Have to admit, a TR8 comes close though!
One of the best engine sounds IMO is the BRM V16, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fZMPDCNyQxE that puts the hairs on the back of your neck up!

shoestring7

6,139 posts

252 months

Wednesday 16th September 2009
quotequote all
AJAX50 said:
The BDA made the Escort into an international winner, the BRM engine bye the way was an H 16, the youtube clip does sound like two V8's!
Mark A S said:
I agree, you can’t beat a Mk 1 or 2 BDA/G/X Escort at 9000rpm in a forest, awesome noise, even from inside the car smile Have to admit, a TR8 comes close though!
One of the best engine sounds IMO is the BRM V16, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fZMPDCNyQxE that puts the hairs on the back of your neck up!
While it makes the ultimate noise, I don't think you could really argue that the BRM H16 was a classic in terms of any noticible success. It was very heavy, had heavy fuel consumption, and what was worse the two-stage superchargers gave logarithmic boost making it undrivable.

Fine in a Spitfire atmore or less constant revs, but hopeless for balancing a car on the throttle.

SS7

amr2

136 posts

208 months

Wednesday 16th September 2009
quotequote all
The You-Tube clip was of a BRM V16 1.5 litre engine from the mid 1950's.

The BRM H16 engine was a 3 litre, unsupercharged, unit dating to the 1966 series of GPs when the engine capacity was increased from 1.5 litres to 3 litres and very few 3 litre engines were available.

The H16 was used by BRM and Lotus in the Type 43, before the DFV came along in early 1967, in the Lotus Type 49.

The H16 was not a particular success!

The V16 does indeed sound magnificent when on full chat.....although nowadays it rarely is given 'the full beans' because of it's fragile nature!

Andrew

Ocarru

143 posts

206 months

Wednesday 16th September 2009
quotequote all
The Lamborghini quad cam V12 has got to be up there. Sounds great, looks great and has been around since the 60s.

As an aside, I remember a journalist called John Simister (I think) who published a book on famous engines - anybody read/recommend it?

shoestring7

6,139 posts

252 months

Thursday 17th September 2009
quotequote all
amr2 said:
The You-Tube clip was of a BRM V16 1.5 litre engine from the mid 1950's.

The BRM H16 engine was a 3 litre, unsupercharged, unit dating to the 1966 series of GPs when the engine capacity was increased from 1.5 litres to 3 litres and very few 3 litre engines were available.

The H16 was used by BRM and Lotus in the Type 43, before the DFV came along in early 1967, in the Lotus Type 49.

The H16 was not a particular success!

The V16 does indeed sound magnificent when on full chat.....although nowadays it rarely is given 'the full beans' because of it's fragile nature!

Andrew
I stand corrected, the first BRM engine was a V layout as you point out.

Here's the power band taken from Wikipedia:

"In Raymond Mays' book, he claimed the following power curve with the 4.0:1 supercharger (5.7 ata):

* 100 bhp (75 kW) @ 5,000 rpm
* 175 bhp (130 kW) @ 6,000 rpm
* 250 bhp (190 kW) @ 7,000 rpm
* 335 bhp (250 kW) @ 8,000 rpm
* 412 bhp (307 kW) @ 9,000 rpm
* 525 bhp (391 kW) @ 10,000 rpm
* 585 bhp (436 kW) @ 11,000 rpm
* 600 bhp (450 kW) @ 12,000 rpm"

SS7

te55gib

36 posts

198 months

Friday 18th September 2009
quotequote all
a8hex said:
bmcoopers said:
what is your opinion of the ultimate engine?
XK

Does everything from winning Le Mans to powering an almost tank
I'd definately agree there - 3.8 on triple webers still sounds, looks, and goes better than most modern lumps!

911stu

648 posts

219 months

Sunday 20th September 2009
quotequote all
Gotta be a flat 6 with no water in it!!!