"Classic Car" or "Classic & Sports Car"
"Classic Car" or "Classic & Sports Car"
Author
Discussion

McClure

Original Poster:

2,173 posts

175 months

Saturday 1st December 2012
quotequote all
This month's Octane has moved me to bin my subscription. Too many new models (new Range Rover? Per-leese); too many watches and too many garage queen auctions.

So, which of "classic car" or "classic & sports car" most deserves my subscription?

Thanks peops.

coffee

BlueMR2

9,455 posts

231 months

Saturday 1st December 2012
quotequote all
I prefer C&SC as well.

Roy C

4,213 posts

313 months

Saturday 1st December 2012
quotequote all
I used to subscribe to both Classic Cars and Classic & Sports Car, but I decided that C&SC was a better read.

McClure

Original Poster:

2,173 posts

175 months

Saturday 1st December 2012
quotequote all
3 for 3. C&SC it is. Thanks chaps.

72twink

963 posts

271 months

Saturday 1st December 2012
quotequote all
C&SC every time!

williamp

20,381 posts

302 months

Saturday 1st December 2012
quotequote all
I tend to buy depending on content rather then a particular magazine. I agree with your thoughts on octane: dissappearing up its own auction report. Motor sport is a good, thorough read but very expensive for a monthly and I cannot justify it every month. I like the cheaper magazines too: the classic cars for sale etc but their articles can be inaccurate. But flicking through many, many cars for sale is a true pleasure of mine.

ClassicMotorNut

2,438 posts

167 months

Saturday 1st December 2012
quotequote all
I prefer C&SC.

RichB

56,213 posts

313 months

Saturday 1st December 2012
quotequote all
Good thread. I've been a subscriber to Octane since issue 6 so am reticent to give up but you've confirmed my suspicions that it's just not as chunky a read as it used to be. I always subscribed to MotorSport and always will, as far as I'm concerned it's the only place to read grown up journalism about all sorts or motor racing form F1 to Stock Cars. As for classic car mags I've subscribed to Classic Cars since my Aston was featured in it in Jan 2012 - seemed rude not to, but you've got me thinking about canning Octane. It's got very lightweight and introspective. The very reason I gave up my Evo subscription, it became more about the journalists than the cars they were writing about!

quiraing

1,649 posts

168 months

Saturday 1st December 2012
quotequote all
Errm, C&SC. Since 1983. Every month. Wish I'd kept them all now. Found a few mid-80s ones recently, very interesting.

stype

16 posts

169 months

Saturday 1st December 2012
quotequote all
Tried many, but always come back to c&sc which I find has consistently better content

marcosgt

11,496 posts

205 months

Saturday 1st December 2012
quotequote all
C&SC - subscriber since the mid 1990s and regular reader before that.

I still look forward to it dropping through the letter box every month!

M.

Mark-C

7,581 posts

234 months

Saturday 1st December 2012
quotequote all
I'm another one for C&SC - seems to be the right mix of the obtainable and the not so!

It's a real shame about Octane though; was a brilliant read for a while.

RichB

56,213 posts

313 months

Saturday 1st December 2012
quotequote all
Mark-C said:
It's a real shame about Octane though; was a brilliant read for a while.
You can tell when Octane started it's decline - the letters page went done in quality significantly, you no longer had letters from Major Blenkinsop Farquarhaquarson Rtd. expanding on the background to the Le Mans Delahay which came a heroic 5th in the 1933 race and instead have people talking about their Dino and complimenting the Editor of the magazine (for the third time) for the excellent article in edition 192 featuring a picture of his their car. Oh and can they please have the "Yard 'o' Lead" pencil, or whatever this months give-away is, for letter of the month biggrin

uk66fastback

18,335 posts

300 months

Saturday 1st December 2012
quotequote all
quiraing said:
Errm, C&SC. Since 1983. Every month. Wish I'd kept them all now. Found a few mid-80s ones recently, very interesting.
Same here. Had loads from the early and mid 80s. When I moved house in 1998 I took them all down to the tip, along with a few dozen Car MEchanics which were my dad's from the 60s (let's change the front shoes on a Wolseley 1500-kinda thing) . Wish I hadn't as I'd love to read them now.


williamp

20,381 posts

302 months

Saturday 1st December 2012
quotequote all
As an aside, its always inteesting to read "old" classic car magazines: the pictures will never be as good (supercar classics excepted) but often they would be interviewing the people invovled, whereas these days they often refer to books or second hand news for the facts. An article by F Wilson McComb would always be worth reading, for example because he never assumed anything.


RichB

56,213 posts

313 months

Saturday 1st December 2012
quotequote all
williamp said:
An article by F Wilson McComb would always be worth reading, for example because he never assumed anything.
Very knowledgable MG chap.

mark387mw

2,205 posts

296 months

Sunday 2nd December 2012
quotequote all
uk66fastback said:
quiraing said:
Errm, C&SC. Since 1983. Every month. Wish I'd kept them all now. Found a few mid-80s ones recently, very interesting.
Same here. Had loads from the early and mid 80s. When I moved house in 1998 I took them all down to the tip, along with a few dozen Car MEchanics which were my dad's from the 60s (let's change the front shoes on a Wolseley 1500-kinda thing) . Wish I hadn't as I'd love to read them now.
Same here.

I couldn't bring myself to throw them out so I've actually shipped them to New Zealand with me.
However, due to everything being online nowadays and only so many articles before they're regurgitated, I no longer subscribe but do buy when I see an interesting front cover!

griffter

4,143 posts

284 months

Sunday 2nd December 2012
quotequote all
I subscribe to c&sc as well. Thoroughly recommended. Balances esoteric with everyday cars, cheque book restos with DIY. The only downside is that being a pher, you get the occasional sense of deja vue...

Caterhamfan

370 posts

199 months

Sunday 2nd December 2012
quotequote all
Another vote for C&SC smile

Gaspode

4,167 posts

225 months

Sunday 2nd December 2012
quotequote all
Yup, I've just dropped my subscription to Octane for exactly the same reasons as everyone else. C&SC remains a consistently excellent read IMO.