Fiesta ST or Red/Black Zetec S

Fiesta ST or Red/Black Zetec S

Author
Discussion

Patent

Original Poster:

804 posts

180 months

Wednesday 16th September 2015
quotequote all
Hello everyone...

Am looking at the above 2 cars to replace a town runabout. Will test drive next week to decide between the two. Any preferences from those that have driven both?

Have been offered ford pcp deals for both. With discounts plus old car as trade in, no additional cash have been offered:
1) ST2, spirit blue - £304 pcm, 36mths,GFV £7.2k
2) Zetec S red - £257 pcm, 36, GFV £6.6

APR 4.3% on both

Has anyone achieved better?

Any advice appreciated.

Cheers

Kidders

1,060 posts

170 months

Thursday 17th September 2015
quotequote all
As a town roundaround, the Zetec S will be more pleasant to drive, the ride is smoother and it will potentially be more economical. Think of it was a warm hatch. I have an ST and a 2012 Zetec-S and I love them both, great fun but the ST is more 'hardcore' as an every day car.

rehab71

3,362 posts

197 months

Thursday 17th September 2015
quotequote all
Patent said:
Hello everyone...

Am looking at the above 2 cars to replace a town runabout. Will test drive next week to decide between the two. Any preferences from those that have driven both?

Have been offered ford pcp deals for both. With discounts plus old car as trade in, no additional cash have been offered:
1) ST2, spirit blue - £304 pcm, 36mths,GFV £7.2k
2) Zetec S red - £257 pcm, 36, GFV £6.6

APR 4.3% on both

Has anyone achieved better?

Any advice appreciated.

Cheers
If you PM me with all the numbers you've been given I'll take a look at the deal, if I'm cheaper you might like to buy it from me! I love doing deals for PHers! smile

Patent

Original Poster:

804 posts

180 months

Friday 18th September 2015
quotequote all
rehab71 said:
If you PM me with all the numbers you've been given I'll take a look at the deal, if I'm cheaper you might like to buy it from me! I love doing deals for PHers! smile
I may take you up on that. At the moment I have secured some quotes through the carwow website that are sinificantly cheaper than my dealer. I will keep you posted.

Thanks for feedback received so far.

Martyboy84

512 posts

160 months

Friday 18th September 2015
quotequote all
Haggle on your st you'll get it below 300 matey.

It's a no brainer.

I went from a mountuned ZS producing around 155ps to the ST.. Night and day! ST is a brilliant car.

Martyboy84

512 posts

160 months

Friday 18th September 2015
quotequote all
Rehab, are you a salesmen for ford at all?

AlanH1

90 posts

148 months

Friday 18th September 2015
quotequote all
Hi, have had two Fiesta ST's, an ST2 and a ST3 on PCP. Great cars, well spec'd, great fun to drive and a good turn of speed. Excellent bang for your buck. Was paying £315 a month on PCP with £100 deposit for the ST3( Which I later discovered could be beaten).

Having had 4 Fiestas in recent years I am just about to get a Zetec S on a lease organised back in May when I sold my ST3. However first vehicle leasing are currently doing a Zetec S for £935 down then 23 months at £155.98 that's maintained and 5k miles. Thats what I am paying for my non maintained car but the excess mileage is only 6p.


Going for a lease as its a good value second car and to stop me changing cars ever 9 months and losing loads on PCP.

Depending on your trade in those prices look a bit high. Maybe I am out of date.

When you get it make sure it doesn't leak, wet boots and front foot wells. 3 out of my four cars have leaked and have been fixed under warranty after several visits to the dealer.


Edited by AlanH1 on Friday 18th September 14:04

Patent

Original Poster:

804 posts

180 months

Friday 18th September 2015
quotequote all
Thanks everyone.
Will test drive Monday and update thread with how I get on.

SpunkyGlory

2,340 posts

172 months

Friday 18th September 2015
quotequote all
I've had two STs and would thoroughly recommend one to anyone.

You mention your old car is trade in, I'm assuming that is acting as your deposit? You can definitely get an ST2 for cheaper than your quoted price, if you would like to send me the figures I'll happily have a look at what's available (not a salesman but have close links to Ford).

rehab71

3,362 posts

197 months

Friday 18th September 2015
quotequote all
Martyboy84 said:
Rehab, are you a salesmen for ford at all?
I'm a business manager at a large Ford dealer

rehab71

3,362 posts

197 months

Friday 18th September 2015
quotequote all
Martyboy84 said:
Rehab, are you a salesmen for ford at all?
I'm a business manager at a large Ford dealer

Martyboy84

512 posts

160 months

Friday 18th September 2015
quotequote all
I'm only a year into my ford options (got an st3 with everything) ,but I'll need to see what deals are around for the new RS smile I won't ruin this topic, but I'll keep an eye on your posts (in a non creepy way!)

rehab71

3,362 posts

197 months

Saturday 19th September 2015
quotequote all
Martyboy84 said:
I'm only a year into my ford options (got an st3 with everything) ,but I'll need to see what deals are around for the new RS smile I won't ruin this topic, but I'll keep an eye on your posts (in a non creepy way!)
They'll be no 'deals' on RS, although happy to look at the numbers for you.

Greg-

167 posts

199 months

Saturday 19th September 2015
quotequote all
rehab71 said:
I'm a business manager at a large Ford dealer
Hendy's by any chance?

Dan Friel

3,821 posts

285 months

Monday 21st September 2015
quotequote all

I went through the same decision.. if I did fewer miles, I would get an ST tomorrow. However, I've now done 15k miles in the Red Edition, and it's brilliant. Great chassis, suspension set up, and one litre turbo engine. I would recommend if you can't have the ST.

Patent

Original Poster:

804 posts

180 months

Tuesday 22nd September 2015
quotequote all
Dan Friel said:
I went through the same decision.. if I did fewer miles, I would get an ST tomorrow. However, I've now done 15k miles in the Red Edition, and it's brilliant. Great chassis, suspension set up, and one litre turbo engine. I would recommend if you can't have the ST.
Agree with this. Maybe I'm getting old but the st(mountune pack) was hard to live with, even on a 30 min test drive. The damping was non existent - it was jumping all over the place on a relatively smooth B road. In every other way it was subjectively better than the Zetec s, which was still a great car.

350zStee

354 posts

178 months

Tuesday 22nd September 2015
quotequote all
If you want something different from the Fiesta, Astons Vauxhall are doing a lease deal on the new Corsa VXR.

Mines is
1 x £197 initial payment
23 x £197
10k miles per year, with optional 18" wheels and carbon pack.

MarkwG

5,093 posts

196 months

Wednesday 23rd September 2015
quotequote all
Dan Friel said:
I've now done 15k miles in the Red Edition, and it's brilliant. Great chassis, suspension set up, and one litre turbo engine. I would recommend if you can't have the ST.
Yep, I agree: 12k behind you, really enjoying ours thumbup

Birdster

2,539 posts

150 months

Thursday 24th September 2015
quotequote all
rehab71 said:
Martyboy84 said:
I'm only a year into my ford options (got an st3 with everything) ,but I'll need to see what deals are around for the new RS smile I won't ruin this topic, but I'll keep an eye on your posts (in a non creepy way!)
They'll be no 'deals' on RS, although happy to look at the numbers for you.
Sorry to thread hijack, but I wouldn't mind if you can let me know what the numbers are looking like for a Focus RS/Mustang.

The lease on my ST ends October 2016 and I'm aware these cars will have a waiting list. I suspect that the Focus RS won't need to be discounted.

With regards to the ST/Zetec S. I'd say ST. You only live once and I can't imagine the fuel economy is going to be that much of an issue if you're not doing that many miles. If you're really just driving around the city it may not be worth it, but I bet you'll find an excuse to go for longer drives.

nwates

376 posts

191 months

Monday 19th October 2015
quotequote all
Have a black edition it's an amazing bit of kit