Dodgy dealing...

Author
Discussion

Omerta

Original Poster:

2,013 posts

256 months

Monday 16th February 2009
quotequote all
My 2003 Golf GTI went in for a routine service with the local VW main dealer last week, including a cambelt change. It's only done 15,000Kms (had 3500 on it when I imported it a year ago!).

A couple of days later I notice a knocking / clicking noise from the engine between idle and 1500 or so, which is louder under load. It makes the most noise with the handbrake on, engaged 1st gear and part release the clutch to put it under load without moving. The clicking is kind of like you hear on a worn CV joint at full lock.

Would a loose cambelt or tensioner make a clicking noise like that? Seems to be from the cambelt end of the engine. I don't think its heavy-metallic enough to be big end (eek), and its not piston slap. I've booked it in for them to look at tomorrow and hoping they'll fess up it was a their error and fix it at no charge, but...

Omerta

Original Poster:

2,013 posts

256 months

Tuesday 17th February 2009
quotequote all
Stumped, or not interested?

Anyway.... 'twas the cambelt tensioner, fixed at no (further!) charge smile

GravelBen

15,832 posts

235 months

Tuesday 17th February 2009
quotequote all
thumbup

Glad they sorted it...wasn't much point speculating when it was going back to them anyway!

Fraster

1,267 posts

245 months

Tuesday 17th February 2009
quotequote all
almost related...I have a friend with a late model HSV who lives in the Wairarapa. he had been taking it to the local Holden dealer for its regular services but he found that around $2500.00 for a simple service was a bit steep. A business colleague of his recommended another garage that he used. The service was duly done, oil & filters changed as per usual:$173.00+gst

Esprit

6,370 posts

288 months

Tuesday 17th February 2009
quotequote all
I would have suggested tensioner but you already did in your first post hence negating any credence my reply might have had smile

jamieheasman

823 posts

289 months

Monday 23rd February 2009
quotequote all
How an HSV can cost that much when Corvettes go a billion miles between services and cost $2.50 is beyond me.