How do we make the trams project a farse?

How do we make the trams project a farse?

Author
Discussion

bi9_jk

Original Poster:

883 posts

271 months

Thursday 18th December 2008
quotequote all
I hate the trams, I don't want them and like many people I know, I dont know anyone who wants them.

That got me thinking, If they are total disaster then hopefully they will be removed anyway.


Lets start a boycott!

Famous Graham

26,553 posts

231 months

Friday 19th December 2008
quotequote all
I think TIE have already comprehensively managed the farce aspect wink

oobster

7,216 posts

217 months

Friday 19th December 2008
quotequote all
There's no way it will be a disaster.

Ok, there may be a few teething problems when they start operating but if customer numbers are not what was expected pressure will be put on the council to make it more difficult to park in the city centre.

Edinburgh is already a nightmare to drive in anyway, I can only see the tram project bringing in more customers for the city centre shops.

Corpulent Tosser

5,468 posts

251 months

Friday 19th December 2008
quotequote all
Not being an Edinburger, or whatever they are called, and always having problems parking in Edinburgh I think the trams are a good idea, I have enjoyed using them in other cities and don't see why they cannot be a success there.

Mattymouse33

1,276 posts

213 months

Friday 19th December 2008
quotequote all
£500M???????? That is a farce in its own!!

boardinscotland

1,226 posts

202 months

Friday 19th December 2008
quotequote all
Mattymouse33 said:
£500M???????? That is a farce in its own!!
And how much was it for the Scottish parliament too???? They love to spend our money. One rule for them and one for us.

onlynik

3,982 posts

199 months

Friday 19th December 2008
quotequote all
Corpulent Tosser said:
Not being an Edinburger, or whatever they are called, and always having problems parking in Edinburgh I think the trams are a good idea, I have enjoyed using them in other cities and don't see why they cannot be a success there.
Neither am I, but I never have trouble parking. I guess I just know where to park.

As it has already been said, Edniburgh has a great bus service, the trams aren't going to help congestion.

WZC1

210 posts

193 months

Friday 19th December 2008
quotequote all
Well I live in Edinburgh and my business is directly effected by the works but I still think it is a good idea. In the short term there will continue to be plenty of upheaval and the way the council is insulting the traders on Leith Walk is out of order but long term the problem in Edinburgh needed to be attacked. Even now when there are a few pockets of road works the streets come to a standstill and that impacts all over the city centre.

The park and ride schemes are helping but the trams will help again and make Edinburgh a city worth visiting in years to come.


Just my 2p's worth

VetteG

3,236 posts

250 months

Friday 19th December 2008
quotequote all
Not to mention the hold ups at the Gyle roundabout with lanes closed while they build the terminus.

G

jshell

11,251 posts

211 months

Friday 19th December 2008
quotequote all
When finance was sought for the trams the cost estimate was £800MM. When the bank being asked for the finance they sought an independant study of other European cities, they came back with a likely total reqd of £1.3 billion. The consortium seeking finance hadn't even looked at the other cities tram development cost, or the fact that most other cities tram systems have never, and will never pay for themselves. It's gonna be worse than the Parliament, a complete waste of cash and Princes St will be shut for 10 months!

The trams stop at the Gyle terminus as permission hasn't been gained to acess the land between there and the airport - owned by 4 seperate people who definitely won't hold the line to ransom. There is also no contract with BAA so they cannot enter the airport boundary either!

I hate Edinburgh City Council for what they do to a fine city.

Oh, and they dug up all these roads to move the 'services', then re-laid the tarmac which will have to be lifted AGAIN to lay the fkin tracks. Aargh!

Oh, and the tracks down Leith walk will be single tracks with 'passing places' which is great as long as one doesn't break down on the single track jamming the whole fvcking works.... Double-Aargh!

Sleekitman

234 posts

192 months

Friday 19th December 2008
quotequote all
Remember when the bus drivers went on strike. All of a sudden no traffic problem. If the trams gets the buses off the main roads around Edinburgh it can only do good. (I'm new here so please be gentle.)

Edited by Sleekitman on Friday 19th December 16:56

Famous Graham

26,553 posts

231 months

Saturday 20th December 2008
quotequote all
jshell said:
Oh, and they dug up all these roads to move the 'services', then re-laid the tarmac which will have to be lifted AGAIN to lay the fkin tracks. Aargh!

Oh, and the tracks down Leith walk will be single tracks with 'passing places' which is great as long as one doesn't break down on the single track jamming the whole fvcking works.... Double-Aargh!
You noticed the paint markings on the left side pavement (as you walk down) after Pilrig? They're shifting the kerb/narrowing the pavement by at least 6 feet.

jshell

11,251 posts

211 months

Saturday 20th December 2008
quotequote all
Famous Graham said:
jshell said:
Oh, and they dug up all these roads to move the 'services', then re-laid the tarmac which will have to be lifted AGAIN to lay the fkin tracks. Aargh!

Oh, and the tracks down Leith walk will be single tracks with 'passing places' which is great as long as one doesn't break down on the single track jamming the whole fvcking works.... Double-Aargh!
You noticed the paint markings on the left side pavement (as you walk down) after Pilrig? They're shifting the kerb/narrowing the pavement by at least 6 feet.
What a disaster in waiting this is! 6 feet? 'Ah shahks ma heid', as Roisin from River City would say......!

jshell

11,251 posts

211 months

Saturday 20th December 2008
quotequote all
Los Angeles said:
How long before the first passenger rushes for a waiting tram, runs upstairs and splits open his head ... before remembering its a tram not a double-decker bus?

yes
How many pints? wink

Famous Graham

26,553 posts

231 months

Saturday 20th December 2008
quotequote all
jshell said:
Los Angeles said:
How long before the first passenger rushes for a waiting tram, runs upstairs and splits open his head ... before remembering its a tram not a double-decker bus?

yes
How many pints? wink
You may laugh, but I've gone to walk "upstairs" on a couple of the single decker 22s biggrin

sam919

1,078 posts

202 months

Saturday 20th December 2008
quotequote all
500 mil and you dont mind if it fails, that was worth the money. Then again if you were into trams you wouldnt be on p'heads.

If you looked at the polution caused by cars to the architecture of one of scotlands finest cities then it may be a different story. Preservation of the city could be ruled into the equation.

Trams are used and do work, just a shame they had to cause so much upheaval in the process.

hugoagogo

23,379 posts

239 months

Saturday 20th December 2008
quotequote all
How much did it cost them to get rid of the trams in Glasgow and Edinburgh years ago?
now 512 million to bring Edinburgh's back
brilliant

what are the chances of getting some of the old ones running on the new network?
here in Düsseldorf you can hire a 'party tram' - an old vintage tram takes you for a drive around with a couple of kegs of beer on board

jshell

11,251 posts

211 months

Saturday 20th December 2008
quotequote all
Famous Graham said:
jshell said:
Los Angeles said:
How long before the first passenger rushes for a waiting tram, runs upstairs and splits open his head ... before remembering its a tram not a double-decker bus?

yes
How many pints? wink
You may laugh, but I've gone to walk "upstairs" on a couple of the single decker 22s biggrin
Thnkyou, and I shall - heartily! rofl

jshell

11,251 posts

211 months

Saturday 20th December 2008
quotequote all
sam919 said:
500 mil and you dont mind if it fails, that was worth the money. Then again if you were into trams you wouldnt be on p'heads.

If you looked at the polution caused by cars to the architecture of one of scotlands finest cities then it may be a different story. Preservation of the city could be ruled into the equation.

Trams are used and do work, just a shame they had to cause so much upheaval in the process.
It's gonna cost £1,300,000,000, you can get a lot of preservation for that! And they're losing cash in every other European city too....

sam919

1,078 posts

202 months

Sunday 21st December 2008
quotequote all
http://www.thetrams.co.uk/tramsinuk.php

I have used the DLR, Croydon and Sheffield services and can truly say they offer a far better mode of transport than cars, buses etc. The DLR cuts out a whole world of morning traffic, same with croydon.

The last two might be closest, but not exact! to the volume of passengers that Edinburgh would be subject to, and with a high amount of tourists to the city it would provide a good source of transport. I would rather see one tram line than three lanes thick of traffic aroud the city.

And for many of Edinburghs residence it would offer a cheaper form of transport, than a car with its inevitable parking charges, into and around the city.

The media cant be relyed on for facts and figures, more example should be taken from excisting succesfull routes, its all to easy to be negtive than proactive in these things.

Edinburgh doesnt have a public transport system for the predicted growth in the city in the future anwyay, so anything implemented is going to cause distruption its part of living in a built up environment.