NIP defence?

Author
Discussion

BEN66

Original Poster:

5,533 posts

217 months

Thursday 1st March 2007
quotequote all
Hi,
I have recently been caught at 51 in a 40 zone, after visiting PEPIPOO the NIP wizard suggested returning the NIP unsigned and ignoring any further correspondence as I live in Scotland. However, it appears that the last time this has been used was in 2004.
Is this still a valid route to take or has there been some progression with regards to the law in this area? I do not want to roll over and take the points but nor do I want three points and a larger fine for failure to provide information. What to do?

Any help much appreciated.
Regards,
Ben

Corpulent Tosser

5,468 posts

252 months

Thursday 1st March 2007
quotequote all
BEN66 said:
Hi,
I have recently been caught at 51 in a 40 zone, I do not want to roll over and take the points but nor do I want three points and a larger fine for failure to provide information. What to do?


How about not doing 51 in a 40 zone ?


dycecooper

632 posts

215 months

Thursday 1st March 2007
quotequote all
Corpulent Tosser said:
BEN66 said:
Hi,
I have recently been caught at 51 in a 40 zone, I do not want to roll over and take the points but nor do I want three points and a larger fine for failure to provide information. What to do?


How about not doing 51 in a 40 zone ?





I think the Horse has bolted on that one

Kiltie

7,504 posts

253 months

Thursday 1st March 2007
quotequote all
Corpulent Tosser said:
How about not doing 51 in a 40 zone ?

... and you've never? ...

confused ... scratchchin ... judge

Corpulent Tosser

5,468 posts

252 months

Thursday 1st March 2007
quotequote all
Kiltie said:
Corpulent Tosser said:
How about not doing 51 in a 40 zone ?

... and you've never? ...

confused ... scratchchin ... judge


Of course I have, and when caught and prosecuted didn't try to get out of what I had done, hands up, "its a fair cop guv"

ASBO

26,140 posts

221 months

Thursday 1st March 2007
quotequote all
BEN66 said:
Hi,
I have recently been caught at 51 in a 40 zone, after visiting PEPIPOO the NIP wizard suggested returning the NIP unsigned and ignoring any further correspondence as I live in Scotland. However, it appears that the last time this has been used was in 2004.
Is this still a valid route to take or has there been some progression with regards to the law in this area? I do not want to roll over and take the points but nor do I want three points and a larger fine for failure to provide information. What to do?

Any help much appreciated.
Regards,
Ben



Old news Im afraid.

Put simply, the loophole that was the non-signing of the NIP has been closed and you will be taken to court for failing to provide information if you do not.

Take the rap like everyone else.

Where were you caught incidently?

BEN66

Original Poster:

5,533 posts

217 months

Thursday 1st March 2007
quotequote all
Caught up in sunny Aberdeen....
And no, its not a 'fair cop'; yes I was (probably) speeding but I do not find the law a fair one, the scamera van was parked just over the crest of a hill on a straight road with no traffic in good conditions. So what, prey tell, is fair about that? I believe that I was driving appropriately for the conditions. I take it you've never breached any limit?....
Edited to say that I have put this thread in the Scotland section and the 'Speed, plod and the law' section and have recieved conflicting replies. Either way, looks like I may have to bend over.....

Edited by BEN66 on Thursday 1st March 17:13

Corpulent Tosser

5,468 posts

252 months

Thursday 1st March 2007
quotequote all
As stated above Ben, I have broken the limit, I have also been caught, I don't like many limits but until they are changed if i break them then it is my fault - personal responsibility and all that !

Corpulent Tosser

5,468 posts

252 months

Thursday 1st March 2007
quotequote all
If you want to try to get aff with it I guy I worked with stated in the return section of the NIP that he did not know who was driving, it was a car which is used by, or at least could have been used by several people. His live in girlfriend was also caught recently in his car and he did the same again.

He requested the photo, and then said he still could not recognise who was driving, there were a number of letters passed back and forth between him and the police/procurator and eventually the police gave up in both cases.

BEN66

Original Poster:

5,533 posts

217 months

Thursday 1st March 2007
quotequote all
Agreed, just p**sed off as I have never been caught before and the circumstances seemed unfair, ultimatley my own fault. Still, would like to avoid the points though, although that seems unlikely.

BEN66

Original Poster:

5,533 posts

217 months

Thursday 1st March 2007
quotequote all
Think I'll just tell the truth andtry to steer clear of perjury, they seem to be cracking down on this at the moment. Loopholes that need no lies, however, are a whole different kettle of fish....

G20RG B

2,745 posts

238 months

Thursday 1st March 2007
quotequote all
I returned the form and ended up with an increased fine £80 and 3 points.
If you know you were speeding Im afraid it is probably best just to pay up and accept the points.aaAAAGGHHH

northo

2,375 posts

226 months

Thursday 1st March 2007
quotequote all
Corpulent Tosser said:
As stated above Ben, I have broken the limit, I have also been caught, I don't like many limits but until they are changed if i break them then it is my fault - personal responsibility and all that !


Agreed. Feel sorry for you and all that but you know the rules. I got caught doing 72 in a 50 that had been changed since the last time I had driven the road. The coppers even said bad luck - my view was I should have been watching the road signs - my fault.

AMCDan

2,769 posts

215 months

Thursday 1st March 2007
quotequote all
BEN66 said:
Caught up in sunny Aberdeen....
And no, its not a 'fair cop'; yes I was (probably) speeding but I do not find the law a fair one, the scamera van was parked just over the crest of a hill on a straight road with no traffic in good conditions. So what, prey tell, is fair about that?


sounds like the one i have here!

A90 North Anderson Drive nr Middleifled Pl, Aberdeen

at 14:57 on 26/01/2007

BEN66

Original Poster:

5,533 posts

217 months

Thursday 1st March 2007
quotequote all
Yup, it is the exact same place 6 days earlier!

D_T_W

2,502 posts

222 months

Monday 5th March 2007
quotequote all
Mine was West Tullos Road, 18:23 on 16/2/07, 55 in a 40. Didn't know the mobile camera vans worked at night, didn't even see it until i was about 100 yards from it, rather hard to spot in the dark! Only got the NIP in on Friday, was hoping i might have gotten away with it as well

hast2

169 posts

219 months

Monday 5th March 2007
quotequote all
D_T_W said:
Didn't know the mobile camera vans worked at night

Was it a forward facing one or did they take a rear photo?
Would think the standard vans that take you head on would not come out due to the intensity of the headlights?

D_T_W

2,502 posts

222 months

Monday 5th March 2007
quotequote all
hast2 said:
D_T_W said:
Didn't know the mobile camera vans worked at night

Was it a forward facing one or did they take a rear photo?
Would think the standard vans that take you head on would not come out due to the intensity of the headlights?


It was one that takes your picture head on, think its a laser but don't actually know. But it was dark, never even saw the bloody thing. Sneaky buggers

jellebabe

8,824 posts

223 months

Tuesday 6th March 2007
quotequote all
They got me too, straight road, clear, dry, hardly a sole about, just a chuffin scamera van, 3points & £60
Whoops

Famous Graham

26,553 posts

232 months

Thursday 8th March 2007
quotequote all
ASBO said:
BEN66 said:
Hi,
I have recently been caught at 51 in a 40 zone, after visiting PEPIPOO the NIP wizard suggested returning the NIP unsigned and ignoring any further correspondence as I live in Scotland. However, it appears that the last time this has been used was in 2004.
Is this still a valid route to take or has there been some progression with regards to the law in this area? I do not want to roll over and take the points but nor do I want three points and a larger fine for failure to provide information. What to do?

Any help much appreciated.
Regards,
Ben



Old news Im afraid.

Put simply, the loophole that was the non-signing of the NIP has been closed and you will be taken to court for failing to provide information if you do not.


No it hasn't and no you won't necessarily.

www.pepipoo.co.uk if you want to dispute it. You'll find plenty of more recent examples there than 2004.

If you know you were driving, know you were doing that speed and so on, then fair enough, take the penalty. If the only indication you've got that you were doing that speed is the NIP itself with no accompanying photo and you don't think you did exceed the limits by that amount, then contest it.




Edited by Famous Graham on Thursday 8th March 15:31