Which Drone?

Author
Discussion

WestyCarl

Original Poster:

3,405 posts

131 months

Friday 13th October 2017
quotequote all
I fancy getting a drone to add to my photographic ability but have no idea which one (although internet research has me leaning towards the DJI Spark)

Main requirements would be;

Good picquality
Portability / ruggedness
Under £750

Any suggestions?

Also what editing software is best. I'm thinking specifically of being able to get a good quality still from a movie, is this possible?

Simpo Two

86,726 posts

271 months

Friday 13th October 2017
quotequote all
WestyCarl said:
I'm thinking specifically of being able to get a good quality still from a movie, is this possible?
If you shoot 4K, yes.

BGARK

5,532 posts

252 months

Saturday 14th October 2017
quotequote all
Following, I am also new to this and looking for the right kit.

I have a particular interest in 3D terrain / architectural mapping if anyone can point me in the right direction?

Thanks. J

R7

170 posts

100 months

Saturday 14th October 2017
quotequote all
I'd be looking at a used Mavic to be honest at that price. The DJI Spark is good however it is more of a hobby-level UAV, marketed at the non-commercial market. Remember, if you intend to use the drone as part of photography as a service or business, you will need a PFCO.

WestyCarl

Original Poster:

3,405 posts

131 months

Sunday 15th October 2017
quotequote all
R7 said:
I'd be looking at a used Mavic to be honest at that price. The DJI Spark is good however it is more of a hobby-level UAV, marketed at the non-commercial market. Remember, if you intend to use the drone as part of photography as a service or business, you will need a PFCO.
Won't be using as part of a business, just a hobby, hence the Spark appealed. Anyone got any experience of one?

Magic919

14,126 posts

207 months

Sunday 15th October 2017
quotequote all
Have a search for the threads on here. There is at least one big one.

Bacardi

2,235 posts

282 months

Sunday 15th October 2017
quotequote all
WestyCarl said:
... I'm thinking specifically of being able to get a good quality still from a movie, is this possible?
Depends on what is acceptable quality to you. The Spark only does max 1080 video resolution, so not really, might be ok for a small snap on FB. 4k is better but if you’re set up for best quality video, with smooth motion blur between frames, it’s still not very good.

The Spark does do 12mp stills, similar to the Mavic, so if you want better quality stills, this is the way to go. Unfortunately the Spark only lets you take JPGs. If they are anything like the JPGs from the Mavic, like all JPGs, a lot of the info is thrown away. Still, better than frame grabbing from the video.

The Mavic does have the ability to shoot in DNG as well as JPG and whilst not the highest quality and suffers from moire in fine details, is waaay better than JPG. Also has the ability to swing the gimbal into portrait mode, which is fun for stills.

So for the budget, I’d look for a s/h Mavic. Not as small as the Spark, but still compact and portable when folded, doesn’t take long to set up, longer flight times, 3 axis stabilisation rather than 2 and more capable overall. The gimbals can be fragile so maybe look to buy from a dealer, with some sort of warranty.

GetCarter

29,559 posts

285 months

Sunday 29th October 2017
quotequote all
Sorry... late to the party with this one.

I have the Phantom 3 pro... which has the same camera as the 3 SE that you can but from DJI.

My 3 has flown at least once a week for the past 27 months and is still going strong. It's a bit bulky, so you might consider the Mavic (same camera).

Here's some of the images I've captured:

http://stevecarter.com/random/Aerial.htm

...and a vid (which looks stunning in 4k)... knocked down to 1080 here :

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VCbHziHvpRs&fe...

By the way, to answer your question, you can get a very decent 'screen res' shot from video, but as mentioned, it's nowhere near as good as a RAW photo taken in flight.

Here's a 'frame' from a vid:




Edited by GetCarter on Sunday 29th October 10:54

mojitomax

1,874 posts

198 months

Thursday 2nd November 2017
quotequote all
Portability = mavic pro. Folds down tote size of a bag of sugar

4K video and 12MP stills in RAW

Can set autopilot waypoint functions for powerful video shots

a good entry/hobby drone.

I love mine