Astra Convertible, but which one?

[pstruck]

Toying with the idea of picking up an Astra convertible. I'm just not sure whether to go for a late, low mileage Mk4 (2005/6) or an early Mk5 Twin Top(2006).

Anyone got any thoughts?

I can see the year round practicality bonus of the hard top on the TT, but to be honest I slightly prefer the more subtle styling and interior of the Mk4. Which is the best ownership proposition though?

[neiljohnson]

Not to sure about the tt but the mrs has had a 2002 turbo for 3 years now & it has been a good car. Has been used in all weathers & have had no problems with the roof at all

Only down points i would say are the sun visors are totally useless & it runs an odd size tyre which can be difficult to get decent ones without specially ordering them, they are not cheap either

[bazking69]

Personally I'd get a late and mint mk4. Much better looking.

[Si_steve]

Another vote for MK4, But im bias

[skidoo]

steer clear of twin top IT WILL STOP WORKING halfway up and the parts are very expensive the whole system is crap and its very heavy 94kg also it will creek,rattle and leak go for astra G ..IMHO

[pstruck]

Thanks for the responses guys, but ended up buying myself and E46 3 series BM vert. Very happy with it.