Z06 beats XKR

Author
Discussion

parklane

Original Poster:

1,446 posts

218 months

Wednesday 1st November 2006
quotequote all
Good to see that the Z06 is still getting positive press coverage against the newer competition. In this months Car magazine our press car beats the new XKR.

If anyone wants to buy a piece of motoring press history, that particular car will be up for sale very shortly...

godzilla

2,033 posts

255 months

Wednesday 1st November 2006
quotequote all
Cool, and as we both know, a certain other thrilling magazine rated my car quite highly against some very expensive machinery...

Front cover story in a couple of weeks time!

anonymous-user

60 months

Wednesday 1st November 2006
quotequote all
Corvette = "the blue collar supercar".

Jag = "the golf club special".



Rob LM

181 posts

244 months

Wednesday 1st November 2006
quotequote all
www.carmagazine.co.uk/video.php?il

You can watch it on their website

Zero journalistic value but it's fairly entertaining.
Having seen a couple of regular XKs I think they're a bit ugly - and performance-wise isn't the standard C6 more like the competition??

cheeky

2,102 posts

270 months

Thursday 2nd November 2006
quotequote all
godzilla said:
Cool, and as we both know, a certain other thrilling magazine rated my car quite highly against some very expensive machinery...

Front cover story in a couple of weeks time!


Dastard! You followed up on that story I told you they wanted to do (yes I know you know them well enough anyway but you hadn't noticed)... I never quite got round to it!

Good to hear it.

On a "completely separate topic", do you know if the next Evo will feature the 997TT and 599GTB?

Marki

15,763 posts

276 months

Thursday 2nd November 2006
quotequote all
But the Jag has class

godzilla

2,033 posts

255 months

Thursday 2nd November 2006
quotequote all
cheeky said:
godzilla said:
Cool, and as we both know, a certain other thrilling magazine rated my car quite highly against some very expensive machinery...

Front cover story in a couple of weeks time!


Dastard! You followed up on that story I told you they wanted to do (yes I know you know them well enough anyway but you hadn't noticed)... I never quite got round to it!

Good to hear it.

On a "completely separate topic", do you know if the next Evo will feature the 997TT and 599GTB?


I can't remember which story you mean. My car was used in the big annual article that a whole issue is being dedicated to. This issue will feature the 599GTB but another 997, the GT3.

cheeky

2,102 posts

270 months

Thursday 2nd November 2006
quotequote all
Oh, is this CoTY then?

godzilla

2,033 posts

255 months

Thursday 2nd November 2006
quotequote all
cheeky said:
Oh, is this CoTY then?


Couldn't possibly say, Harry has me on an embargo until the issue comes out...

lnrd

73 posts

225 months

Thursday 2nd November 2006
quotequote all
godzilla said:
I can't remember which story you mean. My car was used in the big annual article that a whole issue is being dedicated to. This issue will feature the 599GTB but another 997, the GT3.


Hhhmmm, I wonder which car will be voted the winner........ rolleyes

yellowshark454

578 posts

247 months

Friday 3rd November 2006
quotequote all
Rob LM said:
www.carmagazine.co.uk/video.php?il

....
Having seen a couple of regular XKs I think they're a bit ugly - and performance-wise isn't the standard C6 more like the competition??



I saw my first 2 locally a couple of weeks ago with 50yds of each other. A coup and a vert; I would have to say that the vert left its C6 rival standing in the looks dept. by a considerbale margin

Rob LM

181 posts

244 months

Friday 3rd November 2006
quotequote all
Well, most of the UK press seems to agree with you!

i just don't like the lights or the nose and as for the back end...
Maybe it's because it looks a bit like a bad Aston?

vetteheadracer

8,271 posts

259 months

Saturday 4th November 2006
quotequote all
The Jag makes the C6 Z06 look pretty which is going some.

LuS1fer

41,598 posts

251 months

Monday 6th November 2006
quotequote all
Allow me to settle this from an objective point of view. For so called sports cars/GTs, they're both ugly.

Glad to be of service.

anonymous-user

60 months

Monday 6th November 2006
quotequote all
....but if you guys had to have one or the other are we sensing a preference for the Jag?

LuS1fer

41,598 posts

251 months

Monday 6th November 2006
quotequote all
For me, the engine and brute power of the Z06 would mean the Jag wouldn't even get a look in but I'd still have to squint rather than look at it. I still prefer the old XK to the new one and I've seen several of the new ones on the road and find them bland. Yet to see an XKR but doubt it would alter my view.

Cuban

5,161 posts

257 months

Monday 6th November 2006
quotequote all
Personally, I'm totally in love with the looks of the ZO6 and I also like the look of the XKR.

I know looks are subjective, but I do wonder why the C6 / ZO6 is either a hit or total miss
with people when it comes to the styling?
scratchchin

LuS1fer

41,598 posts

251 months

Monday 6th November 2006
quotequote all
For me, the C6 design just doesn't work. I get annoyed just looking at it as a fantastic opportunity missed. I have loved every shape of Corvette up to the C6 based on design detail and flow and in the details that made it different in every iteration - a bit like the Dr Who of sports cars. In the case of the C6, I looked forward to it for such a long time and having imported a Z06 was fully expecting to be blown away by some breathless object of desire. When it arrived, I and a lot of people thought it was a fake. Maybe in isolation, as a generic coupe, it's OK but it doesn't take the Corvette design any further forward and doesn't really capitalise on the past designs if retro was the intention.

The remaining factors are all personal opinions rather than criticisms. I detest the headlamp nacelle. It's shape doesn't match the rest of the car. It's forced, contrived and being the "face of the car", looks characterless and "multi-eyed". The lower air intake looks like it was pencilled in by someone with no design flair at all. When I saw one in the plastic, I thought the side swage line going into the door and the side scoop handles looked like a kit car and as though GM had shunted the clay model to make it shorter. The rear end just looks like a C4 but even the C4 had something to break up the design.

So for me, the design just doesn't hang together, there are too many parts of the car that look as though they were designed separately and overall, it lacks beauty and cohesion and, for me, lacks identity. It could be any old car if you took the badges off and certainly no stunner like some Ferraris. Not that I'd want it to look like a Ferrari, I just wanted something more strikingly aggressive.

Beautiful cars sell themselves and, LHD aside, the relative failure of the C6 to sell means a lot of people must think likewise because the Z06 is perhaps the first Corvette to be widely accepted as a performance and even handling benchmark in Europe and yet it's still not selling like hot cakes. I don't know about Europe where LHD isn't an issue and I don't know if supply is a problem. I do know that my friend went down on Friday afternoon to see a C6 and found the showroom shut. He was allowed access by the sister dealership and was left alone with the car which was er....locked...not exactly the way to seize customers is it? LOL.

Cuban

5,161 posts

257 months

Monday 6th November 2006
quotequote all
Interesting points you make LuS1fer.

Showing again about the subjective nature of looks, the only Corvette I don't feel anything for is the C4.
No offence to anyone who owns one, just does not do a thing for me.

How much is down to the LHD aspect is interesting, but spending a couple of months a year driving in
Continental Europe on the Driving Adventures tours, the Corvette is second only to Porsche on the most
spotted sports car list and I'd say a good 40% were a C6 related model.
scratchchin

Now you may have hit one aspect cleanly on the head. "doesn't really capitalise on the past designs if
retro was the intention."

Corvette have stated that the C6 / ZO6 borrows heavily from the race development program and as such,
effectiveness over styling may have been the intended route?
Clearly they got that right given the rave reviews along the lines of "Finally a Corvette that corners" etc.

Your reference to Ferrari styling "It could be any old car if you took the badges off and certainly no stunner
like some Ferraris." is also an interesting one to me.

I looked at this photo of the Ferrari 599 GTB Fiorano that won "The World's Most Beautiful Automobile" 2006 in
a poll, and perhaps I have a controversial view, but I personally couldn't help but see a resemblance?
scratchchin


As for sales, I'd say apart from the obvious LHD issues, cost is putting people off.
Not that it is too much money, but even I had a physiological mental block to get past.

Say as ZO6 comes in fully loaded in the US at $80k, currently that is just £42,000, so why do we end
up paying £24 more here for one.
yikes

I seriously looked at importing and while it would still be cheaper, that gap narrows to around £8k.
You then of course have to go through the time consuming process of getting it here and from those
I have spoken to, it can become drawn out. You also have no warrantee and perhaps, resale issues
as an import. I personally also feel we should support the UK dealer network or we will loose them. yes

So having gone through all that a) Do you pay what appears to be £24K more or b) Have the
hassle factor and that decision alone 'could' put people off and they go buy an easy option in
say a 911 or a Sagaris.

Just some thoughts...


Edited by Cuban on Monday 6th November 13:57

JenkinsComp

918 posts

253 months

Monday 6th November 2006
quotequote all
Sometimes at weekends I leave my Z06 parked outside my house and can see the car from the front room. No end of people of all ages stop and stand around, looking at it from every angle, peering through the window. People are clearly interested in it's looks. I've seen some people stop for about 10 minutes just to look at it!
It attracted a good deal of attention in Staplefield this weekend, where I went to spectate the London to Brighton run. It was parked alongside many beautiful classics around the green but the Corvette still drew a good share of admirers. (What a great day for the L-B run! Beautiful weather!)

I'd have to say that 90% of all people (including non-enthusiasts) like the cars looks.
You really have to have a pre-formed opinion on the looks to say that it's ugly, I don't think it's the most beautiful shape ever to be drawn, but it certainly isn't ugly.
The Z shape of the creases along the doors, the fat rear arches, the vent in front of the rear wheels - all subtle and effective little touches that give the Z06 an understated muscular appearance.