Collecting accident repaired car

Collecting accident repaired car

Author
Discussion

0ddball

Original Poster:

879 posts

146 months

Tuesday 29th October
quotequote all
Someone sideswiped my other half the other week. He admitted liability and her car went in for repair through his insurance. She was given a courtesy car from the local enterprise.

The body shop (appointed by the other guys insurance) collected the car from our home on a low loader and took it last week.

It's now fixed and ready but they want her to drive there to collect it (leaving the courtesy car there for enterprise to collect). It's only 15 miles away but I think it's out of order that she needs to take time off work to drive there and collect. Apparently their truck driver is on holiday this week (which I don't believe in the slightest) and they need it collecting asap.

Are they within their rights to do this? Or can she insist that it is dropped back off at mutual convenience?


reggie747

135 posts

134 months

Tuesday 29th October
quotequote all
If they picked it up, I'd very much expect (insist) that they drop it back off.
Don't know what their legal implications are here of course.

davek_964

9,291 posts

182 months

Tuesday 29th October
quotequote all
If I was provided a courtesy car, I would expect that I used it to collect my car from the bodyshop. Apart from anything else, I'd want to check over the repair.

I understand the thing about time off work, but it doesn't seem that unreasonable to me.

trevalvole

1,270 posts

40 months

Tuesday 29th October
quotequote all
The other party should put the OP back in the position they would have been in if they hadn't caused the accident, which to my mind includes not having to take time off work to go and collect the repaired car.

119

9,461 posts

43 months

Tuesday 29th October
quotequote all
Cant imagine for one minute they wouldn't be open on a Saturday morning for you to collect.

It's understandable why you feel it should be delivered back to you, but st happens and sometimes we have to work with what we are dealt.


GasEngineer

1,163 posts

69 months

Tuesday 29th October
quotequote all
They seem to have repaired the car remarkably quickly given some of the posts on this forum.

As has been mentioned above, I would want to do a thorough inspection of the repairs before accepting the car back so IMO it would be worth the hassle of driving the courtesy car 15 miles to the repairers.

If you are not happy with the repairs in any way, you have the means to get home again while they sort it.


QBee

21,400 posts

151 months

Tuesday 29th October
quotequote all
Have a think about who is the better person to collect the car, or perhaps even go together.
Then you can both check over the quality of the repair before you relinquish the courtesy car?

E-bmw

9,963 posts

159 months

Tuesday 29th October
quotequote all
However you do it, you need to inspect it there for me, that way if it isn't perfect you just turn around.

FMOB

1,994 posts

19 months

Tuesday 29th October
quotequote all
Just don't accept it back in the dark!

The bodyshop should be open Saturday morning, worth asking.

Most important thing is checking the repair work is acceptable, I would rather do that at the bodyshop. Park the rental car round the corner out of sight, if happy with the repairs then give them the keys.

TheDrownedApe

1,202 posts

63 months

Tuesday 29th October
quotequote all
I am reading this right.

You are moaning about having to drive 15 miles to pick your car up?

Logistics aside; inspect, inspect, inspect and don't take it without it being perfect. We went to collect our car (11miles) and the fog light surround was still cracked. They noted it on the collection form but then we had to chase them for 4 months to actually replace it and even sold the car before it was fixed.

Edited by TheDrownedApe on Tuesday 29th October 19:06

Simpo Two

87,026 posts

272 months

Tuesday 29th October
quotequote all
Most people are happy for an excuse to bunk off work for an hour.

Davie_GLA

6,665 posts

206 months

Tuesday 29th October
quotequote all
So taking time off work to drive 30 mile round trip vs having to be at home and available for a delivery at any point in time?

Take an extended lunch and go get it, at least at that point you can confirm it’s up to standard instead of risking more damage on the back of a truck or at the hands of someone that couldn’t care less about it.

Cutting one’s nose off is rather pointless.

Shinyfings

203 posts

54 months

Tuesday 29th October
quotequote all
Logistics aside you really want to collect it in daylight and with alternative transport home if they’ve done a bad job. If you remove your car and are then unhappy with the repair you will be in a weaker position.

solo2

905 posts

154 months

Wednesday 30th October
quotequote all
As already said inspect the repair work. I had to reject work done on my daughters car twice and even her insurance company paid her compensation (not asked for) because a was a massive f@ck up.

Last time of taking it back I bought a chalk pen and drew all around the areas of damage so there could be no dispute what needed fixing. Finally got it back in pre accident condition.

Would never use that bodyshop again although hope to never need too!

Evolved

3,749 posts

194 months

Wednesday 30th October
quotequote all
It really isn’t with the stress. Drive there, inspect the car, drive away and get on with your day.

ellingtj

305 posts

281 months

Thursday 31st October
quotequote all
Picking it up is a benefit, if they have damaged anything during the repair then it can be raised on their site and not attributed to you after delivery. Watch a video like this (post repair inspection by Professionals Auto Body, it's in the US but gives you an idea of what to look for) https://youtu.be/u56w_-AKPMQ?si=j428sJNfqDFbpj2F and go and inspect it on their premises.

Edited by ellingtj on Thursday 31st October 07:44


Edited by ellingtj on Thursday 31st October 07:44

wolfie1978

459 posts

171 months

Thursday 31st October
quotequote all
If you do this make sure you photo and video the courtesy car when you drop it off, wouldn't want it picking up damage after you've dropped it off in the care of someone else before Enterprise collect and inspect it

Mr Tidy

24,270 posts

134 months

Thursday 31st October
quotequote all
I'd want to go and collect it myself so I could be sure the repair had been done to a satisfactory standard before the courtesy car went!

The Rotrex Kid

31,631 posts

167 months

Thursday 31st October
quotequote all
Mr Tidy said:
I'd want to go and collect it myself so I could be sure the repair had been done to a satisfactory standard before the courtesy car went!
As per the other comments, agree wholeheartedly with this.

My wife’s car was repaired a few years back, they offered to drop it off, we went to pick it up and rejected the repairs, runs in the paint, orange peel on another panel and a badge stuck back on (wonky) with double sided tape (they quoted for a new one!)

Always go and see it check it over before you sign for it or take it, once you’ve got it back, they’re much less interested in helping you out.

Hol

8,696 posts

207 months

Saturday 2nd November
quotequote all
The Rotrex Kid said:
Mr Tidy said:
I'd want to go and collect it myself so I could be sure the repair had been done to a satisfactory standard before the courtesy car went!
As per the other comments, agree wholeheartedly with this.

My wife’s car was repaired a few years back, they offered to drop it off, we went to pick it up and rejected the repairs, runs in the paint, orange peel on another panel and a badge stuck back on (wonky) with double sided tape (they quoted for a new one!)

Always go and see it check it over before you sign for it or take it, once you’ve got it back, they’re much less interested in helping you out.
I agree with this advice.

I have yet to receive a repaired car back, that didn’t have some form of paint defect, or part just plain missing.