Can Sir Keir Starmer revive the Labour Party? (Vol. 2)

Can Sir Keir Starmer revive the Labour Party? (Vol. 2)

Author
Discussion

MC Bodge

24,745 posts

190 months

Thursday 27th June 2024
quotequote all
turbobloke said:
....Stuff...
Why not take a day off?

Please.


119

11,631 posts

51 months

Thursday 27th June 2024
quotequote all
Seems like him and Ange havent really spoken in the last few days.

He's just been on the telly telling us is going to secure our borders, giving home grown talent more opportunity.

Or something.


williamp

19,810 posts

288 months

Thursday 27th June 2024
quotequote all
[redacted]

turbobloke

111,657 posts

275 months

Friday 28th June 2024
quotequote all
Gender is still a problem for Starmer. Did anyone catch the BBC R5 call-in? Apparently there was another uncomfortable moment when SKS clashed with a female caller who wanted to know why Starmer was “not listening to biological women when they say they don’t want to share a space with biological men”. When he didged the question by talking about his time as Chief Prosecutor, the caller replied by accusing him of “absolute twaddle”.

crankedup5

10,917 posts

50 months

Friday 28th June 2024
quotequote all
Labour have a free pass to No 10 this time around, prepare for five years of ineptitude, flip flops,
Starmer will be asking for another five years 2029 following a period of nothingness.
‘smash the gangs’ talk is an insult to the electorate, does he think we do not look at mainland Europe and how they are controlling the migrant crisis. Clue, they can’t and nor can starmer, even though his father was a toolmaker laugh

General Price

5,643 posts

198 months

Friday 28th June 2024
quotequote all
crankedup5 said:
Labour have a free pass to No 10 this time around, prepare for five years of ineptitude, flip flops,
Starmer will be asking for another five years 2029 following a period of nothingness.
‘smash the gangs’ talk is an insult to the electorate, does he think we do not look at mainland Europe and how they are controlling the migrant crisis. Clue, they can’t and nor can starmer, even though his father was a toolmaker laugh
His father certainly made at least one impeccable tool.

I see they are going to come after private pensions again.

Puzzles

2,854 posts

126 months

Friday 28th June 2024
quotequote all
General Price said:
I see they are going to come after private pensions again.
What have you heard/read on this?

FiF

46,748 posts

266 months

Friday 28th June 2024
quotequote all
turbobloke said:
Gender is still a problem for Starmer. Did anyone catch the BBC R5 call-in? Apparently there was another uncomfortable moment when SKS clashed with a female caller who wanted to know why Starmer was “not listening to biological women when they say they don’t want to share a space with biological men”. When he didged the question by talking about his time as Chief Prosecutor, the caller replied by accusing him of “absolute twaddle”.
In fairness he was not allowed to answer but was constantly interrupted. On the other hand the reason he was interrupted is that he was coming up with largely irrelevant anecdotes about his time as a barrister and DPP whilst trying to avoid answering a fairly direct question.

And yes it was diversionary twaddle, mostly.

Vanden Saab

16,061 posts

89 months

Friday 28th June 2024
quotequote all
Oh how perfectly delicious.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/money/tax/labour-priva...

Telegraph said:
Sir Keir Starmer’s planned VAT raid on private schools is likely to breach human rights law.
Lord Pannick, who has taken on some of the UK’s most high-profile court cases, backed legal advice warning that making private schools subject to VAT was likely to breach ECHR law.

Wombat3

13,557 posts

221 months

Saturday 29th June 2024
quotequote all
Puzzles said:
General Price said:
I see they are going to come after private pensions again.
What have you heard/read on this?
Most likely route would be to limit tax relief to basic rate only.

(Cos that won't affect the "working man", only the filthy rich! rolleyes )

hidetheelephants

30,136 posts

208 months

Saturday 29th June 2024
quotequote all
Vanden Saab said:
Oh how perfectly delicious.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/money/tax/labour-priva...

Telegraph said:
Sir Keir Starmer’s planned VAT raid on private schools is likely to breach human rights law.
Lord Pannick, who has taken on some of the UK’s most high-profile court cases, backed legal advice warning that making private schools subject to VAT was likely to breach ECHR law.
Lord Pannick, who attended a private school, is going in to bat for private schools?


Oliver Hardy

3,063 posts

89 months

Saturday 29th June 2024
quotequote all
FiF said:
In fairness he was not allowed to answer but was constantly interrupted. On the other hand the reason he was interrupted is that he was coming up with largely irrelevant anecdotes about his time as a barrister and DPP whilst trying to avoid answering a fairly direct question.

And yes it was diversionary twaddle, mostly.
Went on about how he worked to reduce violence against girls and women, yet the grooming gangs were operating during that time were they not?

hidetheelephants

30,136 posts

208 months

Saturday 29th June 2024
quotequote all
Oliver Hardy said:
FiF said:
In fairness he was not allowed to answer but was constantly interrupted. On the other hand the reason he was interrupted is that he was coming up with largely irrelevant anecdotes about his time as a barrister and DPP whilst trying to avoid answering a fairly direct question.

And yes it was diversionary twaddle, mostly.
Went on about how he worked to reduce violence against girls and women, yet the grooming gangs were operating during that time were they not?
If the police and social services do not send cases to the CPS there's no case for the CPS to do anything with, they are not an investigative body.

768

16,564 posts

111 months

Saturday 29th June 2024
quotequote all
Vanden Saab said:
Oh how perfectly delicious.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/money/tax/labour-priva...

Telegraph said:
Sir Keir Starmer’s planned VAT raid on private schools is likely to breach human rights law.
Lord Pannick, who has taken on some of the UK’s most high-profile court cases, backed legal advice warning that making private schools subject to VAT was likely to breach ECHR law.
And so it begins.

JagLover

44,713 posts

250 months

Saturday 29th June 2024
quotequote all
Telegraph has a rather hysterical article about Labour moving public money away from middle-class areas once in power.

Based on a line in the manifesto "they will enact the socia-economic duty in the equalities act 2010".

If true to any extent I suspect hopes of better public services in exchange for more tax might prove to be incorrect in the leafy suburbs, though I am sure we will see the latter.


isaldiri

21,883 posts

183 months

Saturday 29th June 2024
quotequote all
hidetheelephants said:
Vanden Saab said:
Oh how perfectly delicious.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/money/tax/labour-priva...

Telegraph said:
Sir Keir Starmer’s planned VAT raid on private schools is likely to breach human rights law.
Lord Pannick, who has taken on some of the UK’s most high-profile court cases, backed legal advice warning that making private schools subject to VAT was likely to breach ECHR law.
Lord Pannick, who attended a private school, is going in to bat for private schools?

Lord Pannick who is a noted and very highly regarded lawyer that has dealt with a lot of human rights cases is pointing out a potential problem with ECHR law. Being shocked or not is entirely up to you.

hidetheelephants

30,136 posts

208 months

Saturday 29th June 2024
quotequote all
isaldiri said:
Lord Pannick who is a noted and very highly regarded lawyer that has dealt with a lot of human rights cases is pointing out a potential problem with ECHR law. Being shocked or not is entirely up to you.
A lawyer is arguing that his case is right and the opposite case isn't. It's how law works.

Vanden Saab

16,061 posts

89 months

Saturday 29th June 2024
quotequote all
hidetheelephants said:
isaldiri said:
Lord Pannick who is a noted and very highly regarded lawyer that has dealt with a lot of human rights cases is pointing out a potential problem with ECHR law. Being shocked or not is entirely up to you.
A lawyer is arguing that his case is right and the opposite case isn't. It's how law works.
Do you think Labour will leave the ECHR or just ignore its ruling? I look forward to your reaction when a lawyer in his pyjamas somewhere in the EU puts the legislation on hold. It is shocking that the former DPP is even suggesting it. Just what we have come to expect from the Starnak party though.
Of course he must know his plan is probably illegal being a top lawyer and all so the question then is why suggest it. It seems especially stupid as if it is ruled against it will bring a whole group of people to the leave the ECHR cause.

borcy

7,485 posts

71 months

Saturday 29th June 2024
quotequote all
I think it's possibly best to wait for any theoretical court case to happen before giving too much weight to one person's opinion in a newspaper.

bitchstewie

58,493 posts

225 months

Saturday 29th June 2024
quotequote all
Vanden Saab said:
Do you think Labour will leave the ECHR or just ignore its ruling? I look forward to your reaction when a lawyer in his pyjamas somewhere in the EU puts the legislation on hold. It is shocking that the former DPP is even suggesting it. Just what we have come to expect from the Starnak party though.
Of course he must know his plan is probably illegal being a top lawyer and all so the question then is why suggest it. It seems especially stupid as if it is ruled against it will bring a whole group of people to the leave the ECHR cause.
Is this one the new "but he had a Curry"? hehe